JUDGEMENT
DIPAK MISRA,J. -
(1.)The respondent, NTPC Limited, had issued separate
invitation for bids for development and operation of three coal
mines, viz., Dulanga Coal Block, Chatti Bariatu and Talaipalli
in the State of Odisha. Online bids were invited on Single
Stage Two Envelope Bidding basis (Envelope-I:
Techno-Commercial Bid and Envelope-II: Price Bid). There was
stipulation for Reverse Auction from the eligible bidders. It was
also stated in the Invitation For Bids (IFB) issued on 22.01.2016 that the bids shall be received on 17.03.2016 and
Envelope-I, that is, Techno-Commercial Bid will be opened on
17.03.2016. The date of opening of Envelope-II, that is, Price Proposal shall be intimated separately. Clause 5 of the IFB
stipulated Qualifying Requirements (QR). Clauses 5.1 and
5.1.2 dealt with technical criteria.
(2.)The respondent had also issued "Instructions To Bidders" (ITB) which contain clauses as to how the proposal shall be
conducted. Clause 6.3.1 of ITB deals with Preliminary
Examination of Techno-Commercial Proposals. We think it
appropriate to reproduce the same:-
"6.3.1 Preliminary Examination of Techno-Commercial Proposals:
(a) OWNER will examine the Project Proposals to determine whether they are complete, whether required securities have been furnished, whether the documents have been properly signed and whether the bids are generally in order.
(b) Prior to the detailed evaluation, OWNER will initially determine whether each Techno Commercial Proposal is of acceptable quality, is generally complete and is substantially responsive to the bidding documents. For purposes of this determination, a substantially responsive Proposal is one that conforms to all the terms, conditions and specifications of the bidding documents without material deviations, objections, conditionalities or reservations. A material deviation, objection, conditionality or reservation is one (i) that affects in any substantial way the scope, quality or performance of the contract; (ii) that limits in any substantial way, inconsistent with the bidding documents, the Owner's rights or the successful Bidder's obligations under the contract; or (iii) whose rectification would unfairly affect the competitive position of other Bidders who are presenting substantially responsive Proposals.
(c) OWNER's determination of a Techno Commercial Proposal's responsiveness is to be based on the contents of the Techno Commercial Proposal itself without recourse to extrinsic evidence. If a Techno Commercial Proposal is not substantially responsive, it will be rejected by OWNER, and may not subsequently be made responsive by the Bidder by correction of the nonconformity."
(3.)Clauses 6.3.2 6.3.2.1, 6.3.2.2 and 6.3.4 provide for Evaluation of Responsive Techno-Commercial Proposal,
Evaluation of Qualification Proposals, Evaluation of Technical
Proposals and Clarification Meeting. Clause 6.3.5 deals with
the steps where the responsive Techno-Commercial Proposal
which meets the QR specified in Chapter 7 and Technical
Requirements specified in Chapter 8 of REF Documents and
stipulates that they shall be considered for Price Proposal
Phase of the Bidding Process. It has also been provided therein
that the bidders who meet QR specified in Chapter 7 and
Technical Requirements specified in Chapter 8 of REP
documents shall be terms as "shortlisted bidders". Chapter 7
of ITB deals with technical criteria. Clauses 7.1.1 and 7.1.2,
being significant, are extracted below:-
"7.1.1 The Bidder should have, in the preceding 7 (seven) years reckoned from the date of opening of the Techno-commercial Bids developed and operated single coal/lignite mine having coal/lignite reserves of at least 150 million tonnes and annual capacity of at least 6 MTPA and produced at least 2 million tonnes of coal/lignite from such mine. OR
7.1.2 The Bidder should have, in the preceding 7 (seven) years reckoned from the date of opening of the Techno-commercial Bids, operated and produced:
a) At least 23 Million SCM of aggregated volume of overburden and/or coal/lignite from a maximum of seven open cast mines of Coal/Lignite, in any year.
b) At least 11.5 Million SCM of composite volume of overburden and coal/lignite from single open cast mine in any year, out of which at least 3 million tonnes shall be coal/lignite.
The qualifying works at clause 7.1.2(a) can be from same mine or different mines including the mine considered to meet qualifying requirement at clause 7.1.2(b)."