SANDEEP PODDAR Vs. STATE OF U P

JUDGEMENT

(1.) This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India filed by two petitioners seeking interference of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution with the following prayers:

(2.) The facts as narrated in the writ petition, which raises the controversy, are that the petitioners appeared in Combined Entrance Examination known as U.P. State Engineering Admission Test, 2001 (hereinafter referred to as UPSEAT/ 2001). The petitioners asserted that both the petitioners appeared in the aforesaid test and came out with flying colours. While the petitioner No. 1 was placed at serial number 132 in the Combined merit list and petitioner No. 2 was placed at serial No. 154 among the general category candidates.

(3.) Petitioners thereafter asserted that after the declaration of result, the respondents hold counselling with a view to assign students to a particular college branch disciplines of the engineering according to the merits keeping in view the quota reserved of reservation for various categories of students as explained in the Brochure for the UPSEAT-2001 The relevant portion of the brochure, which has been appended as Annexure-1 is part of this writ petition. The entire brochure is also annexed as Annexure-1 to the rejoinder affidavit which refers at page 25 at item No. 14 under the heading "BASIS OF SELECTION FOR ADMISSION, ALLOTMENT OF INSTITUTION AND BRANCH", reads as under : 14.1. MERIT LIST The merit list will be prepared only on the basis of marks secured by the candidates in UPSEAT Examination. No candidate shall be included in merit list if he/she fails to secure minimum qualifying marks in aggregate in Physics, Chemistry and Mathematics in Group A or Group C; or AG-I, AG-II, AG-III in Group B; or Biology, Physics, Chemistry in Group D; or in the aggregate of all the four subjects in Group E, F, G or H (for direct admission to second year). The Group E, F, G & H candidates may also be considered for admission to first year of different courses depending upon their eligibility (i.e. if they have also passed Intermediate Examination or (10+2) or equivalent and merit. The Aptitude Test in Architecture paper (for Group C & H) shall be of qualifying nature. The merit list of Group C candidates shall be prepared on the basis of total marks obtained by them in Physics, Chemistry and Mathematics papers, based on which they shall also be eligible for admission to first year of B. E./B. Tech/B. Pharma/B. Tech.(Ag. Engg.)/B. Tech. (Technology) courses along with the candidates of other subject groups. They shall be eligible for admission to first year of five year B. Arch. Programme if they also obtain qualifying marks in Aptitude Test in Architecture paper. Thus, no separate merit list of Group C candidates will be prepared.