JUDGEMENT
A.K.ANNAMALAI, J. -
(1.) The opposite parties are the appellants.
(2.) The Complainant filed a complaint against opposite parties 1 and 2 and
against 3rd opposite party claiming for mediclaim policy amount for the
treatment availed at the foreign country for Rs.4,90,225/- (US Dollors
9317.60) and for Rs.5,00,000/- as compensation for mental agony.
(3.) The brief details of the complaint are as follows :- The complainant
had taken overseas medi-claim policy for the period of travel and stay
from April 2004 to October 2004 in USA from the opposite parties. The
opposite parties after thorough medical examination have issued the
policy for Rs.5 Lakh U.S $ and also received premium of Rs.30,560/-. The
policy was issued to the complainant and the complainant left India in
April 2004 to USA to join his son Dr.Sathish, On 12.5.2004, while he was
on morning walk he felt breathlessness for a short while and he was
admitted in Shands Hospital attached to University of Florida, USA as an
outpatient. The lungs specialist Doctor, after thorough examination
discharged the complainant within few hours on the same day. The hospital
preferred a claim of Rs.9317 US dollars for the treatment given to the
complainant. The agent of the 3rd opposite party did not pay the money
though the complainant was in possession of valid insurance policy. At
last the complainant?s son paid the amount to the hospital. On a claim to
the opposite parties, it was repudiated on the ground that the
complainant took chest x-ray in December 2003 and as such he was not
entitled to payment of the bill placed by the hospital authorities. The
chest X-ray was taken only to find out whether there was any enlargement
of the heart and has no relevance to the treatment given by the Shands
Hospital for Hilar and Mediastinaland Lymphaderopathy. The opposite
parties issued the policy only after the senior cardiologists of the
opposite parties, examined him. Hence the reason for denying the
medi-claim policy amount is not convincing and refusal is nothing but
deficiency in service. The disease referred by Shands Health Care USA is
not pre-existing disease since only in the year 2004 complainant was
affected with breathlessness while he was on morning walk and took
treatment in Shands Hospital. Hence, the complainant filed the complaint
claiming Rs.4,90,255/- (US dollars 9317.60) paid by him and also a sum of
Rs.5,00,000/- as compensation for mental agony.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.