JUDGEMENT
A.K.ANNAMALAI, J -
(1.) The unsuccessful complainant is the appellant.
(2.) The complainant filed a complaint against the opposite party for
negligence and deficiency of service in giving the medical treatment and
claiming compensation for Rs.15,00,000/- and for mental agony and to pay
medical bills etc., amounts spent for 6 days in the hospital and
Rs.3,000/- as costs.
(3.) The brief details of the complaint are as follows :- The complainant
approached the opposite party on 14.12.03 with pain in his right hip and
leg. After taking various tests including X-ray, MRI scan etc. On
17.12.03 he was admitted to the opposite party hospital for dynamic Hip
Screw surgery as advised by the opposite party for a sum of Rs.50,000/-
spent approximately as charges and accordingly he got admitted on
19.12.03 and on 23.12.03 operation was performed and the sutures were
removed on 15th day. Subsequently samples for biopsy was sent and on the
basis of the biopsy report further test of isotope scan was taken and on
that basis the complainant was advised to undergo for 2nd operation for
Total Hip Replacement surgery by spending another Rs.75,000/-. The
complainant underwent second surgery on 12.1.2004 and the complainant
signed in blank papers few minutes before the operation by stating that
they are all formalities and as per the request made by the opposite
parties medicines and blood units were all supplied by the complainant
except for some of the medicines supplied from other shops and when the
Doctor came to know that the medicines and blood supplies procured from
some other blood banks and medical shops other than the places mentioned
by the doctor where he was having tie up and developed animacity and ill
feeling towards the complainant and thereby from the next day he refused
to give treatment and for a week only the opposite party hospital staffs
gave tablets and injections and when the complainant and his relative met
the opposite party and explained to him the circumstances for the
purchase of medicines from other places since the complainant himself as
a chemist but he refused hear the same and angrily reacted. The
complainant paid Rs.1,50,000/- in cash on various dates apart from the
expenses of medicines and blood. At the time of discharge when the
complainant asked for cash receipts and break up for the amounts paid by
him it was evaded and the discharge summary also was not given
immediately and only after adamantly insisted by the complainant
discharge summary was given without date. The discharge summary does not
disclose the true facts of the treatment and the dates etc. The intention
of the opposite party for non giving the X-rays discharge summary etc.,
not to undergo further treatment from any other doctor. The lack of
service ends in the permanent disablement of the petitioner. Hence a
lawyer notice was sent on 29.4.04. No reply was given only on 14.1.06 the
opposite party was handed over MRI Scan report alone and still X-rays
with-held by the opposite party he refused to hand over it. The
complainant even after two surgeries was not able to walk still suffers
from severe acute pain due to false assurances promises and failure to
examine the complainant after for one after the major second surgery.
Hence there is medical negligence and deficiency on the part of the
opposite party for which the complaint is filed for the reliefs as stated
above.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.