JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) HEARD the parties.
(2.) THIS appeal by the Appellant -Insurance Company is directed against the award of interim compensation awarded by the Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Tribunal, Godda in Title Claim Case
No. 47/05 and directed the Insurance Company to pay a sum of Rs. 50,000.00 .
It appears that on 16.4.2005 the deceased was dashed by a truck bearing registration No. BR - 36 -2590 and the deceased died at the spot. The owner of the vehicle appeared and contested the case stating, inter alia that the vehicle was insured with the Appellant - United India Insurance
Company Ltd. The appellant, who was respondent before the Tribunal also filed a written
statement and contested the case. In paragraph No. 6 of the written statement although the
Insurance Company stated that the policy filed in the case appears to have been issued by the
United India Insurance Company Ltd. Ramgarh Branch, Hazaribagh but the said policy does not
mention any number in the column certificate number is blank so verification is to be made. Taking
into consideration the factum of accident and the stand taken by the Insurance Company the
Tribunal prima facie held that vehicle was insured and accordingly the impugned award has been
passed.
(3.) IT was seriously argued by the Counsel for the appellant that policy was not issued by the Appellant -Insurance Company from its Ramgarh Office and therefore the award against the
appellant cannot be sustained in law. In order to satisfy ourselves by order dated 15.2.2007 the
lower court record was called for and the Counsel appearing for the owner of the vehicle was
directed to produce the original policy and the receipt showing payment of premium for the relevant
period. In compliance of the aforesaid direction the owner of the vehicle filed affidavit annexing the
original policy but stating that the receipt was lost. Mr. Lal learned Counsel for the appellant
referred various documents and argued that the alleged original policy is a fake document and it
was never issued.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.