JUDGEMENT
D.K.SINHA, J. -
(1.) THE petitioner, Devi B. Parikh has preferred this Criminal Revision application against the order impugned dated 6.5.2004 passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, F.T.C. VII, Jamshedpur in S.
T. No. 14 of 2004 arising out of Bistupur P.S. Case No. 229 of 2000 whereby and whereunder the
prayer of the petitioner for her discharge was rejected.
(2.) THE prosecution story in brief is that the informant, Devgam Ram delivered his statement before Bistupur Police at M.G.M. Hospital, Emergency Ward at bed No. 6 on 18.11.2000 at about 17.45
hours that on 17.11.2000 he had been to Mihtila Motors Ltd. to attend his duty where he was
assigned work to deposit a sum of Rs. 2,30,000.00 of the company. He took the same amount and
came to Adityapur Branch of Punjab National Bank where he deposited Rs. 52,000.00 and with
the remaining amount he came to Bistupur Branch of certain bank for deposit. He further narrated
that while he was checking the voucher slips at about 12.30 noon at the receipt counter, a person
come near him and attracted his attention that some notes were lying on the ground. As soon as
he leaned on the ground the person took his bag and fled away from the gate. Though he raised
and no sooner did he arrived at the gate the unknown person had already escaped. He lodged a
First Information Report at the Bistupur Police Station. He further alleged that on 17.11.2000 at
about 12 O 'clock noon one Sumit Guha, General Manager and another Rajesh Agarwal
Accountant, both of Regent Hotel along with 4/5 persons took him to a room of Regent Hotel and
asked him to confess his guilt that he had misappropriated the amount and assaulted him brutally
and thereafter drop him at his home extending threat not to disclose the matter to the police.
However, he was taken to the M.G.M. Hospital by his brother and got him admitted for treatment.
On the basis of the fardbeyan a case for the offence under Sec. 342/323/34 of the Indian Penal Code was registered and subsequently Sec. 325/326/307 was added in the FIR. After
investigation the police charge -sheet against the petitioner and others under the aforesaid
sections of the IPC. The CJM took cognizance of the said offence and committed the case to the
Court of Sessions Judge, Jamshedpur.
(3.) MR . S.L. Agarwal, learned Counsel submitted that the case was originally instituted against Sumit Guha, Rajesh Agarwal, Senior Executives of Regent Hotel and 4/5 unknown persons. In his fard -
beyan before the police the informant did not reveal the complicity of the petitioner regarding her
involvement in the alleged offence and even during the investigation the police had examined five
witnesses on behalf of the prosecution but no overt act was attributed against the petitioner by
any of the witnesses. Advancing his arguments Mr. S.L. Agarwal submitted that the petitioner is an
infirm and rich lady and in order to extract some money, the informant implicated her in his
restatement that only on her instruction he had gone to Regent Hotel as she had communicated to
him that he would be interrogated by Sumit Guha and pursuant to such instruetion he had visited
Regent Hotel where he was assaulted by the accused persons by putting pressure to confess his
guilt admitting misappropriation of the balance amount. The injuries of the informant was examined
at MGM Hospital, Jamshedpur and as many as six multiple bruises were found on him caused by
hard and blunt substance within 48 hours and all the injuries were simple in nature.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.