JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) Invoking the inherent power of this Court as incorporated
under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (in short "the
Code"), the petitioner has prayed for quashing of entire criminal
proceeding as well as the order dated 12.04.2013 taking cognizance of
offence under Sections 120 -B and 409 of I.P.C. as also under Sections
13 (2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of Prevention of Corruption Act in connection with R.C. Case no. 11(A) of 2011 -D.
(2.) Bereft of unnecessary details, the facts, which is relevant for the proper adjudication of the issue involved in this criminal
miscellaneous petition, in short, is that at the instance of the
Superintendent of Police, C.B.I./ACB/Dhanbad, the aforesaid case
was instituted under Sections 120 -B read with Section 420 and 409 of
I.P.C. and also under Sections 13 (2) read with Section 13(1)(d) of
Prevention of Corruption Act against several accused persons
including the petitioner, who was posted as General Manager in
Kustore Area, BCCL, Dhanbad with the allegation that information
has been received from reliable source that the petitioner and other
accused persons conspired among themselves and abusing their
respective official position as Public Servant dishonestly
misappropriated 3,02,246.121 MT of coal stock during check period
2009 -11. Whereafter, physical measurement of the coal stock at Rajapur Open Cast Project, Kustore Area was carried out by a team
of officials of C.B.I. and B.C.C.L. Vigilance in assistance with Technical
Survey Officers and during their joint surprise checking, coal stock to
the tune of 3,11,052.879 MT was physically found, whereas, as per
records, the book stock of coal was 6,13,299 MT on 02.08.2011. So, there
was a noticeable shortage of coal to the tune of 3,02,246.121 MT causing
loss of Rs.54 crores and odd to Bharat Coking Coal Limited and
corresponding wrongful gain to themselves and others. The shortage
was beyond the permissible limit of 5% as per the provisions contained
in the Code for Uniform System of Maintenance, Control and
Verification of Coal Stock (commonly known as "Yellow Book") issued
by CIL during January 1992. The General Manager, Agent/Project
Officer and Manager of the concerned colliery were held to be
responsible for coal shortage in view of the clause 66 (iv) of the said
"Yellow Book".
(3.) After investigation, C.B.I. submitted the detailed charge - sheet stating therein that investigation as prima facie establish that this
petitioner along with Shailendra Kumar Singh - the Project Officer and
Sunil Kumar Pathak Manager posted in Rajapur Open Cast Project,
Kustore Area, Dhanbad entered into a criminal conspiracy among
themselves and in furtherance of the said criminal conspiracy, they
dishonestly mis -appropriated 2,83,044 MT approximately i.e. 47% of
coal of ROCP Kustore Area worth Rs. 27,80,08,647.74 approx, which
was entrusted to them in their dominion and control in their respective
capacities as public servant but they abused their respective official
position as public servant. The sanction for prosecution of the petitioner
and other two accused persons are accorded by the competent authority
and are enclosed with the charge -sheet.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.