JUDGEMENT
APARESH KUMAR SINGH,J. -
(1.) Heard learned counsel for the parties.
(2.) The award at Annexure-11 passed by the respondent no.2, Jharkhand Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council communicated through
memo no. 3342 dated 12.12.2013 is under challenge in the present writ
petition by the petitioner. The award impugned has been passed under
Section 18(3) of the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development
Act,2006 in case no. JHMSEFC No. 01/2013 on a reference made by applicant
- supplier/respondent no.3. The applicant/supplier is said to be a Small
Enterprises Firm registered with District Industry Centre, Ranchi on whom
order was placed on 1.10.2012 by the buyer/petitioner for supply of 2
lakhs kg of HTS wire valuing L 112.77 lakhs with payments to be made
within 30 days from the date of delivery. Another purchase order for
supply of specified description of HTS wire for a value of L 107.73 lakhs
was also placed on 29.11.2012 with payments to be made within 30 days
from the date of delivery. Applicant claims to have supplied consignment
amounting to L 1,65,64,314/- in accordance with the purchase order on
various dates to the buyers against which part payment of L 25,86,752/-
were made on 22.12.2012.
(3.) Aggrieved with the delay in making payments, the applicant/supplier filed the reference on 4.2.2013 under Section 18(1) of the Act of 2006
before the Council for realisation of outstanding dues of L 1,39,77,562/-
towards principal and L 2,60,997/- towards interest up to 31.1.2013
supported by affidavit of the applicant and certified by a Chartered
Accountant. On 12.2.2013 the reference was admitted by the Council and
registered notices to the buyer/petitioner along with the claim petition
of the applicant/supplier were sent on 13.2.2013 directing him to appear
on 5.3.2013 and file his objection/written statement, if any up till
28.2.2013. The Buyer/petitioner appeared in the proceeding on 5.3.2013 and preferred an application under Section 8 of the Arbitration &
Conciliation Act, 1996, requesting the Council to stay the further
proceeding in Case No. 1/2013 claiming that prayer is not maintainable
under Section 18 of the Act of 2006. He also filed a Misc. Case No.
16/2013 (N) before the Additional District Judge, Barasat (West Bengal) under Section 9 of the Arbitration & Conciliation Act, 1996 which on
contest, by the order and judgment dated 14.5.2013 was rejected. This
order was also placed before the Council. Petitioner preferred an appeal
before the Hon'ble Calcutta High Court in F.M.A. 1945 of 2013 along with
an application vide C.A.N. No. 6439 of 2013 for staying of the
proceedings pending before the Council. The Stay petition was disposed of
without any order as to costs on 8.7.2013 with an observation that " we
have made it free for the parties to make their respective contentions
before the tribunal". The next date fixed for filing objection by the
opposite parties/petitioner was 17.6.2013. A Junior Counsel appearing on
behalf of the opposite party prayed for time on the ground that
conducting lawyer has to appear. Time was allowed to the opposite parties
by way of last chance to file written statement against the claim of the
applicant by 19.8.2013, so that Council would hear the matter. The case
was again taken up on 2.9.2013. However, on the said date also prayer of
adjournment was made by the Junior Counsel for the Buyer/petitioner by
way of adjournment petition stating that the opposite parties had invoked
the arbitration clause pursuant to which arbitration proceedings are
pending before the Sole Arbitrator, Kolkata. The said prayer of the
petitioner/buyer was rejected by the Council. It appears that on failure
of the parties to arrive at a settlement through conciliation Under
Section 18(2) of the Act of 2006, respondent-Council in exercise of power
Under Section 18(4) of the Act of 2006 proceeded to decide the dispute
between the parties. Thereafter, it dealt with the merit of the claim of
the applicant and declared the Award under which the petitioner/buyer has
been directed to make payment of principal outstanding amount of L
1,39,77,562/- up to 31.8.2013. It also directed that the Buyer/petitioner shall pay interest of L 26,61,381 from 10.11.2012 to 31.8.2013 on the
principal outstanding @ 3 times of Bank Rate notified by R.B.I,
compounded with monthly rests in terms of Section 16 of the Act of 2006.
The interest will occur till the date final payment is made.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.