JUDGEMENT
M.Y.EQBAL, D.K.SINHA, JJ. -
(1.) These two appeals filed by the claimant and by the insurance
company are directed against the judgment
and award dated 26.5.2005 passed by the
Third Additional District Judge, Dhanbad
in Title M.V. Suit No. 85 of 1997 whereby
a sum of Rs. 22,70,000 has been awarded
to the claimant for the injuries sustained
by him in a motor vehicle accident.
(2.) The facts of the case lie in a narrow compass:
The claimant Vinay Kumar Sah was in
the service of BCCL and was working on
the post of Assistant Colliery Manager at
Simla Bahal Colliery, Bhalgara area. On
15.6.1996 while he was coming from his
duty to his residence at Singh Nagar Officer's Colony, Jharia by his scooter, he was
dashed by a truck bearing registration No.
AP 9-U 5058. The truck was running in a
very high speed and was being driven rashly and negligently and dashed the claimant,
as a result of which he fell down and both
of his hands came under the wheel of the
truck. It was stated that due to the said
accident, both hands of the claimant were
completely damaged and he became totally
and permanently disabled. The respondent
contested the claim by filing written statement taking various defences including
that amount of compensation claimed by
the claimant is baseless, imaginary and
highly inflated. The Claims Tribunal after
considering the entire evidence came to the
conclusion that appellant insurance company is liable to pay compensation. While
assessing compensation, Claims Tribunal
found that at the time of accident, claimant
was getting salary of Rs. 10,000 but when
he was examined as witness, according to
his pay slip, he was getting basic salary of
Rs. 17,867. The Tribunal further held that
on account of loss of fingers in the accident
the monetary loss sustained by the claimant
is to the extent of 15 per cent of his basic
pay as an underground allowance. Tribunal
after taking gross income of the claimant
at Rs. 20,000 and taking 60 per cent of the
said amount, i.e., Rs. 12,000, principle of
multiplier was applied and the compensation amount was assessed at Rs. 22,70,000
and awarded the said amount together with
interest at the rate of 6 per cent per annum
payable for a period of two years till the
date of the award.
(3.) M.A. No. 136 of 2005 has been filed
by claimant with a grievance that interest
should be allowed on the ground that interest has not been awarded in accordance
with law.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.