JUDGEMENT
TAPEN SEN, J. -
(1.) THE petitioner in the instant case prays inter alia for promotion to the post of Reader/Professor in Economics on the basis of the statutes relating to promotion of reader/professors. According to the
petitioner, she is working as a Lecturer in Economic in the A.S. College, Stasang at Deoghar for
thirty years and is eligible for being promoted on the basis of the statutes framed by the University.
(2.) IT would be relevant to note that the petitioner had earlier moved the Patna High Court vide C.W. J.C. No. 3029 of 1993 which was dismissed by a Division Bench by order dated 25.1.1995, giving
liberty to the petitioner to file a representation and the respondents were given three months time
to dispose off the same by a speaking order. At paragraph 8 of the counter affidavit it has been
stated that pursuant to the aforesaid order, the petitioner filed a representation on 24.4.1995, and
after considering the same, the University decided to pay the due amount of arrears till full amount
was not received from the State Government. So far as her Promotion was concerned, it was
stated in the same paragraph that the same is pending with the then Bhagalpur University,
Bhagalpur and the case of the petitioner will be considered when necessary informations are
furnished by the jharkhand public Service Commission for purposes of scrutiny of the candidates
who are found fit for promotion.
It is not necessary to go into the other details because in the Amendment Application filed by the writ petitioner, a document has been brought on record vide Annexure 8 thereto and it is a letter
No. 49 written by the Deputy Secretary. Higher Education to Registrar, Sidhu Kanhu University,
Dumka. This, document relates to the previous pay fixation in the U.G.C. Scale of various teaching
staff of the University and the name of the petitioner has been mentioned at Sl. No. 15 thereof.
Column No. 6 of the chart shows that the concerned authorities have mentioned that the
"admissible" date of promotion is 1.2.1985. In other words, it appears from this document that the
petitioner is entitled for promotion from 1.2.1985, Mr. M.S. Anwar, learned counsel appearing for
the University has stated that in view of the amendment brought about in Section 35 of the
Jharkhand State Universities (Amendment) Act, 2002 it is the State Government which has to
furnish the list of experts to the University for purposes of scrutiny of eligible teachers so that they
can be given time bound promotion. It appears that initially under the provisions of Sec. 58(8), it
was the Vice -Chancellor who had the power to select candidates for appointment in consultation
with the Public Service Commission, but such selection was to be made from the panel/list
prepared by the Inter University Board. However, by reason of Sec.35 of the Jharkhand State
Universities (Amendment) Act. 2002, the words 'Inter University Board ' has been
substituted and the words "Directorate of Higher Education, Government of Jharkhand" has been
inserted. In that view of the matter and taking note of the document brought on record vide
Annexure 8, this Court considers it apt and appropriate to direct the Director, Higher Education,
Government of Jharkhand to look into the matter and if it is mandatory for the Government to send
the list of experts to the University for constitution of a Screening Committee, then he shall supply
such list to the University within a period of four months from the date of production/receipt of a
copy of this order. Upon receipt of the same the University in its turn, shall do the needful in
accordance with law and in accordance with the relevant statutes. The University shall complete
the process within another period of four months from the date of receipt of the list indicated
above. Let is be recorded that the salary sheets which have been brought on record by the
petitioner vide Annexures 9 and 10 appended to supplementary affidavit filed on 15.4.2004, were
issued by the University describing the petitioner as a Reader in Economics. Similarly a certificate
has been issued by the Principal of A.S. College, Deoghar describing the petitioner again as a
Reader. This fact will be duly taken note of by the University at the time of doing the needful as
indicated above. The writ petition stands disposed of. There shall however be no order as to costs.
Whatever salary the petitioner is receiving at the moment will not be disturbed till the matter is
finalized by the University as indicated above.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.