JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) THIS application is directed against the order dated 5.7.2013
passed in Complaint Case No.1148 of 2012 whereby and whereunder cognizance
of the offences punishable under Sections 406, 420, 468, 471/34 of the Indian
Penal Code has been taken against the petitioner.
(2.) BEFORE adverting to the submissions advanced on behalf of the parties, the case of the complainant needs to be taken notice of.
It is the case of the complainant that Rev.Joseph Minz (accused no.1) was appointed as Bishop of Simdega Catholic Diacesan in the year 1993
who continued to hold the said post till 10.4.2008. Being Bishop of Simdega, he
was also acting as Ex.Officio President of Simdega Catholic Diacesan Education
Society. While Rev.Joseph Minz was holding the said post, he called the
complainant to his office and conveyed to him that under a Project of the Society,
several buildings for schools, hostels, residences and a community hall are to be
constructed for total estimated cost of Rs.321 crores and 45 lacs. The said money
provided by the foreign country has been received at Reserve Bank of India.
Further it was told that for getting the said money released, 1% of the said
amount is to be deposited with the Reserve Bank of India but such a huge
amount is not with the Society and if the said money is arranged by him, it would
be repaid with interest at the market rate and that he would be given preference
in awarding contract for construction of the aforesaid buildings. The complainant
agreed for that. The complainant in between 2007-09 paid a sum of Rs.65 lacs to
the accused no.1 on being convinced by letter of authority given by the members
of the governing body including the petitioner, authorizing the said Rev.Joseph
Minz to receive money on behalf of the Society. Subsequently,
when the complainant did find that nothing is happening in the matter, he made
request to the accused no.1 and also the members of the governing body to pay
back him money. After much persuasion, a sum of Rs.9.50 lacs was paid to the
complainant in the month of December, 2008 and the accused persons promised
to make payment of rest of the money. Thereafter later on, when the complainant
did approach the accused persons for return of the money, he was shown another
project report showing construction of the building for the estimated cost of Rs.40
crores. When nothing was done in this regard, the complainant became quite
suspicious and then made enquiry and during enquiry, he came to know that all
the accused persons, who were members of the governing body of Simdega
Catholic Diacesan Education Society including the petitioner in connivance with
each other had prepared a false Project report, letter of authority in order to cheat
the persons and in this manner, it has been alleged that the complainant was put
to loss of Rs.55.5 lacs.
(3.) ON the said allegation, a complaint was lodged which was registered as Complaint Case No.1148 of 2012 in which cognizance of the
offences punishable under Sections 406, 420, 468, 471/34 of the Indian Penal
Code was taken against the accused person including the petitioner, vide order
dated 5.7.2013 which is under challenge.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.