JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) HEARD learned counsel for the parties. The petitionerschool has come before this Court for seeking
a direction upon the respondents to grant it minority status.
According to the petitioner, the said school is running since 1972 and
imparting education to the members largely belonging to the
minority community in the said locality where it is situated as per the
syllabus prescribed by the Government, for which it was granted
temporary recognition by office order dated 231st March, 1974
(Annexure1).
It is the contention of the petitioner that its application for
being declared as religious and linguistic minority school was made
vide Annexure3 dated 1st October, 1992 and as per the decision of
the District Establishment Committee, the D.S.E. Dhanbadcum
Bokaro was directed to forward the application of the petitioner to
the competent authority. Vide Annexure5 dated 8th March, 1994,
the D.S.E. DhanbadcumBokaro forwarded the application through
Regional Deputy Director, North Chhotanagpur, Hazaribagh to the
competent authority i.e. Director, Primary Education, Bihar, while
Annexure6 was issued in furtherance thereof by the Regional
Deputy Director of Education dated 12th July, 1994 to the Director,
Primary Education. Thereafter, the correspondences took place
between the office of the Deputy Director, Primary Education and
the D.S.E., DhanbadcumBokaro, but finding no positive results, the
petitioner represented before the Director, Primary Education,
Jharkhand for taking a decision in the matter of declaration of
minority status of the school vide his letter dated 30th July, 2001
(Annexure8). Again the petitioner was directed to submit
documents and according to the petitioner they were complied with.
It is submitted on behalf of the counsel for the petitioner that the
respondents have not yet taken any decision over the matter and
affidavit has only been filed on behalf of the D.S.E., Dhanbadcum
Bokaro, wherein it has been stated at paragraph 7 that the matter is
pending before the Director, Primary Education, Jharkhand, Ranchi.
(2.) LEARNED counsel for the petitioner, therefore, submits that the petitionerschool has a right to be considered for being declared as a
religious and linguistic minority school to which it is entitled
keeping into account the relevant factors and criteria as are required
by the RespondentsState. In these circumstances learned counsel
for the petitioner has submitted that the respondent no.3, Director,
Primary Education, Human Resources Development Department,
Government of Jharkhand, be directed to take an appropriate
decision on the application of the petitioner, as no final decision has
been taken till date.
Learned counsel for the RespondentsState, on the other hand, relying upon the affidavit of the respondent no.5 submits that the
petitionerschool have been making a claim on the basis of a
temporary recognition issued in the year 1974 and there is a minority
school existing within a distance of 100 meters from the present
school itself. However, it does not appear that any final decision
either way has been taken by the competent authority on the
application of the petitioner to claim religious and linguistic minority
status as per which the petitioner may be entitled to the benefits as
are permissible under the fundamental rights guaranteed under the
Constitution.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and gone through
the relevant materials on record. It appears that especially the
respondent no.3 has not arrived at any decision on the application of
the petitioner for declaration as a minority school although the
correspondences on the application of the petitioner has been taking
place since long. In these circumstances, the petitioner is permitted
to approach the respondent no.3, Director, Primary Education,
Human Resources Development Department together with all
supporting facts and necessary documents within a period of 3 weeks
in respect of its claim for declaration as a religious and linguistic
minority school. In case, such a representation is being made before
the respondent no.3, Director, Primary Education, Human Resources
Development Department, he shall consider the same in accordance
with law and circulars of the RespondentsState and take an
informed decision in respect of the said claim within a period of 12
weeks thereafter by passing a reasoned and speaking order, which
shall also be communicated to the petitioner.
With the aforesaid observations/directions, this writ
application stands disposed of.;