JUDGEMENT
MOHAMMAD RAFIQ,J. -
(1.) This writ petition seeks to challenge the award dated 10.09.2015 passed by the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council at Odisha, Cuttack (for short 'the Facilitation Council') in claim application filed by the respondent, M/s. Sigma Engineering Private Limited, whereby the petitioners have been directed to pay an amount of Rs. 37,15,000/- towards principal and Rs. 69,20,659/- towards interest.
(2.) Facts of the case are that a tender was floated by State of Rajasthan for construction of vertical lift steel gates of Suk li- Selwara Dam Project in Sirohi District, Rajasthan. The respondent being successful bidder/tenderer, was issued work order for a sum of Rs. 4,71,35,000/- in the year 2005. As per the petitioners, in spite of receiving amount of Rs. 4,64,75,000/- out of the total amount, respondent-firm did not complete the work within the stipulated time frame. Even though the work was completed with inordinate delay, there were certain defects in the construction which were to be rectified/corrected. Despite several reminders by the petitioners, the aforesaid defects were not rectified/corrected by the respondent, owing to which the petitioners had to get the said work done through another contractor incurring extra expenditure. On account of all these facts, dispute arose between the parties.
(3.) Mr. J.M. Saxena, learned Additional Advocate General submitted that Clause 23 of the agreement executed between the parties provided for reference of any such dispute to the Standing Committee for settlement and if the decision of the Standing Committee was not acceptable, the aggrieved party was free to approach concerned civil court, as per Clause 51 of the agreement, having jurisdiction over the place where the agreement was executed. The respondent, instead of raising the dispute before the Standing Committee or approaching any civil court in the State of Rajasthan, approached the Facilitation Council. Despite objection raised by the petitioners about jurisdiction of the Facilitation Council, the said Council vide impugned award dated 10.09.2015, has required the petitioners to pay the respondent a sum of Rs. 37,15,000/- towards principal amount and Rs. 69,20,659/- towards interest.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.