BHAL SINGH Vs. STATE OF RAJASTHAN
LAWS(RAJ)-2007-2-74
HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN
Decided on February 01,2007

Bhal Singh Appellant
VERSUS
STATE OF RAJASTHAN Respondents

JUDGEMENT

CHATRA RAM JAT, J. - (1.) THIS appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 03.04.1998 passed by the Sessions Judge, Anti Corruption Cases, Bikaner in A.C.D. Case No. 36/97 (9/90) whereby the charges under Section 7 and 13(1)(d) read with Section 13(2) of the Anti Corruption Act, was proved against appellant, Bhal Singh, and he was declared guilty for the same. Thereafter he was heard on the point of sentence and was convicted and sentenced for six months rigorous imprisonment under Section 7 and fine of Rs. 500/- was also imposed. He was further convicted and sentenced for offence under Section 13(2) for a period of one year's rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 500/- and in default of payment of fine, he has to go for one month's rigorous imprisonment.
(2.) PROSECUTION case is as under : On 22.9.1989 Sukh Deo Singh (PW1) went to Anti Corruption Department, Sri Ganganagar, and presented a complaint Ex.P1 to the Additional Superintendent of Police Shri Radhey Shyam Sharma (PW9) wherein he stated that he is resident of village Rampura (Narainpura) and doing agriculture work in village 5 IDG of Rajasthan which is adjacent to Punjab. Village of Sukhedeo Singh is on border of Rajasthan and Punjab and in between there is bridge over the canal and he used to come and go and Bhal Singh is RAC guard on this side and demanding bribe for coming and going. He also stated that on that very day in the morning about 8-9 A.M. when he brought one bufallow and Pada in tractor and crossed the bridge towards Rajasthan Side of Narainpura village, on the corner he was intercepted and demanded money, then he said that when he cut four rounds of mustard crop then he will pay Rs. 61/- at the rate of Rs. 15/- per round and Rs. 10/ - of this round, in total Rs. 70/- was to be paid. Sukh Deo Singh requested that he did not want to pay this illegal amount and wants to caught the culprit red handed on spot. On receiving this complaint, Shri Radhey Shyam Sharma, after due enquiry, arranged a trap and took signatures and two witnesses Jai Singh, Susheel Kumar were called for the purpose. In presence of witnesses Rs. 70/- (five notes of Rs. 10/- and one Rs. 20/- currency note) were taken and noted its number then put signs over currency notes, then phenolphthalein powder was spread over these currency notes by Ram Gopal L.C. and the same were given to Sukhdeo Singh Complainant. He was instructed that after giving the currency notes to RAC guard, pass signal by putting hand on turban or tell nearby going. Both witnesses were directed to remain near complainant and try to hear the conversation. When fingers of Ram Gopal L.C. was washed out the water became pink and solution was thrown and empty bottle of phenolphthalein was put in record. Hands of Ramgopal were washed by soap and requisition of additional force from local police was sent and at 4.50 they started to border check post 85 RD link channel. At 7.15 P.M. from Dhani of Ami Lal Bishnoi, complainant and police started with tractor PBF 181 loaded with mustard towards bridge for crossing channel. In the tractor Hansraj, Ram Kumar Bishnoi and complainant was therein and when reached near about 200 yards, then complainant said to Radhey Shyam that post is about 200 yards and when they will with him then there will be suspicion in the mind of RAC guard. Jeep and checking party stayed there. Complainant moved with tractor and reached near Bahal Singh (Bhal Singh) and stopped the tractor after giving bribe. At about 8 P.M. complainant gave signal to trap party and on receiving the signal, trap party reached to spot and gave identification and asked the name of bribe taker. On asking he said his name is Bahal Singh (Bhal Singh) LC 0802 RAC IVth Battalion. On asking about bribe of Rs. 70/- from complainant, he refused to take the bribe and one thing rolling from left pocket of the pant was fell down on earth. Sukh Deo Singh and Hansraj informed that Bhal Singh took Rs. 70/- and put the same in left pocket of pant then allowed to across the tractor from bridge. Thereafter fingers of Bhal Singh were washed in Sodium carbonate solution and left hand became 'matmela' and right hand finger's solution became pink. Solution was kept in two bottles and were sealed. In presence of motbirs, money was recovered near feet of Bhal Singh and on checking the same numbers of currency notes were found.' Pant of Bhal Singh were taken in possession with bundle of 'biri' and match box which also dipped in sodium carbonate solution then. It became 'matmela' and reverse pocket of the pant was also dipped in the sodium solution which turned into pink, the same were kept in sealed bottle for chemical examination. Thereafter usual fards were prepared and sent to head office for registering FIR which is Ex.P13. After complying with all formalities and investigation, Exp-12 charge-sheet was filed for offence under Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) read with section 13(2) and accused denied the charges and claimed for trial.
(3.) PROSECUTION in support of its case examined Sukh Deo Singh PW1, Sushil Kumar PW2, Jai Singh PW3, Hansraj PW4, Sudarshan Kumar PW5, Laxman Singh PW6, Ram Gopal PW7, Gauri Shankar PW8, Radhey Shyam Sharma PW9, Hazari Lal PW 10, Banney Singh PW11, and Nawal Kishore PW12. Thereafter statement of accused appellant Bhal Singh under Section 313 Cr.P.C. was recorded and stated that he caught dry wooden loaded truck of Sukh Deo Singh so he falsely implicated him. After hearing the counsel for the parties, learned Sessions Judge convicted and sentenced the accused appellant. During the pendency of appeal, accused appellant Bhal Singh expired on 05.10.2000. Thereafter an application under Section 394 Cr.P.C. was filed to take on record legal heirs of Bhal Singh and that application was allowed vide order dated 22.11.2000. Hence, this appeal is prosecuted by his legal heirs as mentioned hereinabove.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.