JUDGEMENT
Ajay Rastogi, J. -
(1.) Instant appeal has been filed by owner of offending I vehicle challenged the award dated 25th September, 2004 in MAC No. 1193/2004 whereby Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (Special Judge, E.C. Act), Jaipur City awarded compensation of Rs. 12,75,787/- to the claimant injured, who became 100% disabled in the accident.
(2.) Claimant aged 35 years while going to Bari Chaupar (Jaipur) as a pillion rider on a Luna moped No. RSA-7471 driven by Smt. Kiran Rajput met with an accident with offending truck No. HR-68-0118 in front of Hawa Mahal coming from their behind being driven rashly and negligently by its driver on 16th May, 2001 at 11.40 a.m. - as a result whereof the claimant sustained grievous injuries and causing 100% permanent disability as opined by Medical Board. Claimant, as alleged, was Assistant Teacher serving in Rajendra Bal Mandir, Dariba Pan, Jaipur, and earning Rs. 6,750/- per month as is evident from certificate produced by her. Taking note of salary to the tune of Rs. 6,750/- per month, the learned Tribunal after deducting Rs. 1,500/- for her personal expenses, assessed financial assistance to her family to the tune of Rs. 5,250/- per month and keeping in view her age 35 years, adopted multiplier of 16 and finally awarded compensation of Rs. 12,75,787/- (including Rs. One lakh each towards loss of married life and for mental agony, pain and suffering due to 100% permanent disability and Rs. 50,000/- towards future treatment and Rs. 17,787/- for medical bills) vide impugned award.
(3.) Counsel for appellant contends that in support of her salary as claimed of Rs. 6,750/- no material has been placed on record except certificate issued by the School, which in no manner can be attributed to arrive at the conclusion that her monthly salary was of Rs. 6,750/-; as such finding recorded by learned Tribunal while awarding impugned compensation to the claimant on the basis of her salary as Rs. 6,750/- requires interference by this Court. Counsel further contends that it was a case of contributory negligence as is evident from site plan (Ext. 3), Smt. Kiran Rajput who was driving Luna moped whereon claimant was pillion rider, was equally negligent for the accident in question; as such finding recorded by learned Tribunal in respect of negligence of offending vehicle only is not corroborated by material on record.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.