JUDGEMENT
Ajay Rastogi, J. -
(1.) Instant appeal was filed by claimant-injured for enhancement
of compensation awarded by Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal, Neem Ka Thana
(Sikar) in M.A.C.T. No. 45 of 1992.
(2.) Facts, in brief, are that on fateful day,
8.10.91 at 7 p.m., appellant along with his
family members was going on his camel
cart from Ranoli to village Sankhuna Ki
Dhani on National Highway No. 11, when
reached near Bus Stand, Bawri Ke Balaji,
offending truck No. RRL 7181 coming
from behind with a high speed being driven
rashly and negligently had collided with
camel cart which resulted in causing grievous injuries to them.
The camel succumbed
to grievous injuries at the spot and the cart
was completely smashed. As per medical
certificate dated 25.1.1995 (Exh. A45),
since the claimant sustained grievous injuries
including posterior head injury on
hemiplegia with difficulty in speech and
epileptic fits with 100 per cent disability,
was not in a position to record his oral
statement before Tribunal; as such his wife
Jinki recorded as his power of attorney
holder, statement and that apart, Mohanlal,
AW 2 (brother) and Chawli, AW 3 (brother's wife)
also appeared in witness-box
to support the claim petition. Fact which
emerges from their statement was that earning of
appellant was Rs. 100 per day from
camel cart and he had also 8-10 bighas of
agricultural land from which he used to
earn Rs. 1,500 per month to support his
family consisting of seven daughters and
one son who were dependent upon him
along with his wife. Appellant was hospitalised in
Neuro Ward in SMS Hospital,
Jaipur, from 8.10.1991 to 22.10.1991 and
also produced medical bills along with
other documents in support of claim for
compensation of Rs. 25,30,263.
(3.) For adjudication of the dispute, in all
six issues were framed. On the basis of
material on record, with regard to issue
No. 1, the Tribunal recorded finding that
claimant has been medically certified with
100 per cent disability and no contrary
evidence is available to dispute it and as
such, Tribunal proceeded to compute compensation
payable to claimant being 100
per cent disabled. But without there being
any contrary material on record with regard
to issue No. 2, Claims Tribunal determined
income of appellant at Rs. 750 per month
and with the aid of multiplier of 9, awarded
Rs. 81,000 towards loss of income;
Rs. 6,000 as medical expenses, Rs. 35,000
towards mental and physical suffering and
Rs. 6,000 towards loss of camel and cart.
The Claims Tribunal awarded Rs. 1,28,000
towards total compensation.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.