JUDGEMENT
R.S.Chauhan, J. -
(1.) The appellant has challenged the award
dated 6-9-2002 passed by the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal, Tonk, whereby the learned
Tribunal had awarded a compensation of
Rs.61,000 for 25% permanent disability
suffered by the appellant in a road accident.
(2.) The brief facts of the case are that on
16-3-1996 when the appellant was travelling
in a tanker, on National Highway No.12, a
truck, bearing registration No. RJ 26 G-221,
being driven rashly and negligently, collided
with the tanker. Because of the said accident,
the appellants suffered a fracture of left leg,
the left hand and also sustained injuries on
his fingers, the and hand and the heel. He
also sustained three stitches on his eye-brow
and 10-12 stitches on his head. According to
the disability certificate issued by the doctor
he had suffered 25% of permanent disability.
In order to receive some compensation, the
appellant filed a claim petition before the
learned Tribunal. In order to substantiate his
case the appellant examined himself as a
witness and submitted twenty-two
documents. The non-claimants neither
examined any witness nor submitted any
document. After going through the oral and
documentary evidence produced by the
appellant, the learned Tribunal was pleased
to grant the compensation as aforementioned.
Since the appellant is still not satisfied with
the said award, he has filed this appeal before
us.
(3.) According to Mr. Sandeep Mathur, the
learned Counsel for the appellant, the
appellant's left leg has been shortened by
four centimeters. For the rest of his life, he
would have to limp while walking. His
permanent disability, as stated above, is 25%
According to the learned Counsel Item 5 of
the Second Schedule attached to the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 (hence forth to be referred
to as 'the Act', for short) prescribes a formula
for calculating the compensation in case of
non-fatal accidents. In case the said formula
were applied the actual income loss would
have to be multiplied by multiplier of 18. But
the said formula has not been applied by the
learned Tribunal. Hence, the Tribunal has
failed took apply proper provision of law.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.