VIJAY SINGH PUNIA Vs. R S B P W P
LAWS(RAJ)-2003-3-19
HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN (AT: JAIPUR)
Decided on March 07,2003

VIJAY SINGH PUNIA Appellant
VERSUS
RAJASTHAN STATE BOARD FOR THE PREVENTION AND CONTROL OF WATER POLLUTION Respondents

JUDGEMENT

ANIL DEV SINGH, C. J. - (1.) By this writ petition, which has been filed by way of a Public Interest Litigation, the following reliefs have been claimed : "(i) that by a suitable writ, order or direction the non-petitioner No. 3 be directed to take immediate steps against these unauthorised factories and restrain them from discharging toxic wastes and effluents into the canal and land; (ii) that non-petitioner No. 5 further be directed to check the raising of unauthorised construction of factories without compliance of the statutory provisions of Section 25 of the Act of 1975 and impose penalties on the factories found violating the statutory provision; (iii) any other writ, order or direction which this Hon'ble Court may deem just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case be passed in favour of the petitioner; (iv) that cost of the petition be awarded to the petitioner."
(2.) The petitioner is aggrieved by the inaction of the respondents, since they allegedly failed to implement the provisions of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 (for short, "the Act") and they were not able to check the construction and growth of the unauthorized factories, responsible for discharging toxic wastes and effluents into the canal and on land, and it is pointed out in the petition that several unauthorised industries/factories have been set up in large numbers at Sanganer, in Villages, Gujron-ki-Talai, Hazyawala, Kesyawala and Muhana. These factories/industries, which have been set up in these areas, are situated along the canal from Sanganer Anicut to Newata Dam. According to the petitioner, the factories/industries have been set up and some are in the process of being set up on agricultural land, without prior permission. The factories are carrying on business of dyeing and printing of cloth. The prints, created by them are called Sanganere Prints and are famous world over. While they bring glory to the country, at the same time, the factories/industries discharge toxic substances, namely, acids, chemicals, colours, bleaching powders etc., in the aforesaid canal. Bulk of the factories have not installed any pollution-control devices with the result that the canal-water is being polluted. The canal, carrying poisonous effluents, leads to Newata Dam. This dam was constructed for utilizing its water for irrigation as well as drinking purposes. According to the petitioner, the effluents, reaching the dam, through canal, are causing serious health hazards and are also causing irreparable injury to the environment, man and animals etc.
(3.) Pursuant to the notice issued in the writ petition, replies have been filed by respondents Nos. 3, 5 and 8. Respondent No. 3, the Rajasthan State Board for the Prevention and Control of Pollution (for short, "the Pollution Control Board") in its reply dated 10-2-95, has stated to the effect that it is tackling enormous task of controlling discharge from all-over Rajasthan. It has been pointed out that Pali was a problematic area and the Board concentrated its efforts for curbing water pollution in that area. In the reply, it is also asserted that due to untiring efforts of the Board a Common Efluent Treatment Plant (for short, "CETP") was constructed, which was to take care of treatment of ten million gallons of effluent from various textile units of Pali. In so far as the problem of discharge of effluent in the aforesaid canal, by the printing units, is concerned, the Board alludes to the fact that a survey was conducted in September, 1991. According to the survey, 240 dyeing and printing units were found to be working in Sanganer. The Pollution Control Board, after conducting the survey, came to the following conclusions :- (i) Half of the effluent is contributed by discharge of domestic as well as industrial effluents from Wards Nos. 8, 9 and 10 of Sanganer, into Amani Shah Nalah, which leads to Gular Dam. The water of Gular Dam is used for irrigation purposes. The remaining half of the effluent from these wards, is discharged into natural cavity, known as Pili Khana, located near Jaipur-Sawaimadhopur Railway Line. (ii) Domestic as well as industrial effluent from the western part of Sanganer Town, is discharged into drains, which leads to Kumawat-ki-Dhani, near Jaipur-Diggi Railway Line. (iii) The effluents from the industries, situated in Khatri Colony, on New Sanganer Road, is discharged into open land, since there is no drainage system. (iv) None of the industries in Sanganer, has installed an effluent treatment plant. (v) The problem is compounded by mixing of domestic and industrial effluents, which lead to the water sources and open land.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.