JUDGEMENT
Sunil Kumar Garg, J. -
(1.) This writ petition
under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India has been filed by the petitioner against
the respondents on 25-2-1992 with a prayer
that by an appropriate writ, order or direction,
the respondent-University may be directed to
confirm the provisional merit certificate issued
to the petitioner No. 3-10-1991 (Annex.3) and
it may further be directed to declare that the
petitioner is entitled to get the merit certificate
as well as the Gold Medal as a result of her
first position in B.A. Examination, 1991.
(2.) That it may be stated here that this
Court vide order dated 17.8.92 allowed the
application of Smt. Deepti Lodha for
impleading her as party in this writ petition
and she was impleaded as respondent No. 2
in the writ petition.
(3.) The facts as put forward by the petitioner
are as under:-
(i) That the petitioner secured 71st
position in her Secondary School
Examination held by the Board of
Secondary Education for Rajasthan
at Ajmer in the year 1987. She
secured 26th rank in her higher
Secondary Examination in the year
1988 and 4th rank in her Senior
Higher Secondary examination
held in the year 1989. A photocopy
of mark-sheet of Senior Secondary
Examination is marked as
Annex. 1.
(ii) That further case of the petitioner
is that at the time the petitioner
passed her higher secondary examination,
the Board of Secondary
Education for Rajasthan introduced
a Scheme of 10+2 examination
and an option was given to
the candidates either to take admission
in the Senior Higher Secondary
Class i.e. 12th Class or to
take admission in the first year of
three years degree course.
(iii) That the petitioner opted for 12th
Class and she passed the same in
the year 1989.
(iv) That after passing the Senior
Higher Secondary examination,
the petitioner got admission in the
Second Year of Three years degree
course in the University of Jodhpur
(respondent No. 1).
(v) That the petitioner topped the
B.A. Final examination, 1991 as
she secured 74.75% marks. A
copy of mark-sheet of B.A. examination,
1991 is marked as Annex.
2, which reveals that she secured
897 marks out of 1200
marks.
(vi) That the further case of the petitioner
is that through certificate
dtd. 3.10.1991 (Annex.3). the
petitioner was awarded merit certificate
stating that she stood first
in B.A. Examination, 1991 held
by the respondent No.1.
(vii) That further case of the petitioner
is that she came to know that the
University was going to award gold
medal to the student who stood
first in B.A., but name of the petitioner
was going to be excluded
for getting the gold medal and
therefore, she submitted representation
dtd. 7-1-92 (Annex.4) and
representation dt. 9.1.92 (Annex. 5)
and ultimately, she sent a
notice for demand of justice
31.1.92(Annex.6).
(viii) That she came to know that gold
medal would not be awarded to the
petitioner despite the fact that she
secured first position in B.A. examination,
1991.
(ix) That the petitioner submits that the
gold medal should have been
awarded to the petitioner and for
that respect, reliance has been
placed on Ordinance 301 of the
Jodhpur University Ordinance
which reads as under:
"Medals:
Ordinance 301. "The university
will award Gold Medals every year
to students who stand first class
first in Final degree and Post-graduate
Examinations of the University."
(x) It has been further submitted that
because of Ordinance 301, the
claim of the petitioner should have
been accepted by the respondent
No.1. Hence, this writ petition
with the abovementioned prayer.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.