JUDGEMENT
M.M.Kumar,J. -
(1.) The prayer made by the petitioner in the instant petition is for
quashing order dated 29.9.2001(Annexure P-2) passed by the Controller of
Defence Accounts(Pension) and also the order dated 21.10.2003 (Annexure P-5)
issued by the Director General Personal Services,respondent No.2 rejecting
the claim of the petitioner for disability pension. The petitioner has also prayed
for issuance of direction to the respondents to grant him disability pension with
effect from the date he was invalidated out of service with interest at the rate of
12 per annum.
(2.) Brief facts of the case are that the petitioner was enrolled in the
Army as Rifleman on 15.10.1993. At the time of his entry into service, he was
subjected to medical examination and was declared fit as no physical or mental
disorder was detected. The petitioner started suffering from mental disturbance
and epiliptic seizure, which led to the convening of medical Board. On 4.2.2000,
he was medically examined and it was declared that he was suffering from
Generalized Seizures BEE V-67. A copy of the order has been placed on record
as Annexure (P-1). Accordingly, the petitioner was boarded out of service and
the certificate dated 4.2.2000 shows that the disability suffered by the petitioner
was attributable to and aggravated by the Military Serviced. The petitioner
applied for grant of disability pension, which has been rejected on 29.9.2001 by
respondent No.4 on the ground that the disease was constitutional in nature and
it was neither attributable not aggravated by Army service. The appeal filed by
him was also rejected by respondent No.2 on 21.10.2003.
(3.) The respondents has filed written statement and in para No.1, the
stand taken is that the petitioner does not fulfill the minimum conditions for grant
of disability pension as per the requirement of Regulation 173 of Pension
Regulation for the Army 1961. According to respondent, disability of the
petitioner was assessed at 20 % as is evident from the perusal of para 4 of the
reply. It has also been asserted that the petitioner has been paid numerous
monetary benefits on his discharge, which are as under:-
(a) Invalid Gratuity 34,650/-
(b)Terminal Credit Balance 32,678/-
AFPP Fund 78,902/-
(d)AGI Register Disability Elements: 37,500/-
(e)AGI Regular Maturity Benefits 9,403/-
(f)DCRG 2,9700/-;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.