JAGDISH SINGH Vs. JASMER SINGH
LAWS(P&H)-2014-5-99
HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
Decided on May 27,2014

JAGDISH SINGH Appellant
VERSUS
JASMER SINGH Respondents

JUDGEMENT

K.KANNAN, J. - (1.) THE appeal is for enhancement of claim for compensation for injuries suffered in a motor accident. The accident took place on 25.03.1995 in which the claimant had suffered serious injuries which were assessed to have resulted in permanent disability to the tune of 20%. The claimant was a Head Constable and there was evidence to the effect that he was unable to attend his duty for nearly 42 days. The Tribunal assessed a compensation of Rs.80,000/ -.
(2.) ALTHOUGH the claimant had contended that he had been under a long leave, the Tribunal observed that there was no proof brought from official records to assess whether he had suffered any loss of pay. I will not find any error in the assessment. As regards the cost of medicines, the Tribunal reasoned that the medical bills filed in court Exs.P2 to P29 had not been properly established by proving through the doctor that the medicines purchased had been under his prescription and they related only for treatment of the claimant. I will not look for such extracting standard of proof and allow for Rs.25,000/ - as the cost of medicines. He had been undergoing a treatment including an operation which was last performed in the year 1999, although the accident took place in the year 1995. I do not have really any information about the cause for such a long treatment even if he resumed duty. I will, therefore, provide for a modest increase of Rs.25,000/ - by way of compensation for pain and suffering. The Tribunal's assessment has been reasonable fair as regards the compensation provided for the disability on account of 20% permanent disability as assessed by the Tribunal. The various heads of claims are tabulated as under: - Date of accident: 25.03.1995 Jagdish Singh Age: Period of hospitalization: more than 42 days Occupation and income : Head Constable Heads of Claim Tribunal High Court Sr. No. Amount ' Amount Rs. 1. Loss of income from to 2. Medical expenses: 10,000 i) Medicines 25,000 ii) Hospital charges iii) Attendant charges iv Special diet 10,000 10,000 v Transportation 3. Pain and suffering 20,000 25,000 4. Disability 20% 20% 5. Loss of earning power in percentage i) Income ii) Multiplier 6. Loss of amenities 40,000 40,000 7. Reduction in life expectancy 8. Loss of prospect of marriage Total 80,000 1,00,000 There shall be an award of Rs.1 lakh and the additional amount secured through this award will attract interest at 7.5% per annum from the date of petition till date of payment. The right of enforcement shall be available against the Insurance Company.
(3.) THE award stands modified and the appeal is allowed to the above extent.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.