JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) This writ petition has been filed to bring it to the notice of the
Court that pipeline channel laid down for discharge of sullage water of city
Abohar in a drain namely Abdul Khurana Drain is overflowing and
destroying crops of the petitioners and other farmers. It is further averred
that discharge of untreated water in the said drain is resulting into
contamination of groundwater making it unfit for drinking purposes.
(2.) After issuance of notice of motion many effective orders have
been passed from time to time. At one time, Local Commissioner was also
appointed to assess the loss caused to the farmers. After looking into the
report of the Local Commissioner, this Court passed the following order on
5.12.2011:-
"On the last date of hearing we had appointed
Mr. R.S. Bains, Advocate as a Local Commissioner to go into
various questions. Mr. Bains requests for more time to
complete his report. However, Mr. Toor learned counsel for the
petitioner has pointed out that some interim relief could be
given to the petitioner if disposal from point 'A' (in the site plan
placed before us) is diverted to site 'AA' by digging a
temporary drain. Size of the area for digging would be about
two kilometers as per the Local Commissioner. Before granting
any interim relief of the aforesaid nature we have impressed
upon Mr. Sehgal, learned Additional Advocate General, Punjab
to convene a meeting of the Officers by associating Mr. R.S.
Bains so that the feasibility of the suggestion made may be
examined. The necessity of such a nature has arisen because
the sowing season of the Rabi crop is almost coming to an end
and the huge track of about 400 acres of land could be saved
and sowing can be still undertaken.
For the aforesaid purpose let the matter be listed
again on 9.12.2011.
A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of
connected case."
(3.) By the aforesaid orders, the district administration was directed
to convene a meeting in association with the Local Commissioner so as to
examine the feasibility of the suggestions made to solve the problem. On
9.12.2011, following order was passed by this Court:-
"Order dated 11.5.2011 would show that the
learned Addl. A.G., Punjab has made a categorical statement
that compensation @ Rs. 5,000/- per acre for the year 2011-12
in respect of 217 acres of land would be disbursed within a
period of three months from the date of the order. The period of
three months had expired in August, 2011 but the compensation
has not been paid so far to the writ-petitioners and other
farmers, who have su ered the loss. We direct that
compensation may now be paid on or before 20.12.2011. Mr.
Sehgal states that the compensation shall be paid before the
adjourned date of hearing. Any further claim over and above
Rs. 5,000/- may also be put forward by the counsel for the
petitioners by siting the rates given for similar purpose by the
Collector in the area.
In respect of short term and long term measures to
be adopted for stopping the flooding of the land of the
petitioners an affidavit has been filed by Sh. Satish Chandra,
Principal Secretary to Government of Punjab, Department of
Local Government on behalf of respondent No.1. Wherein in
para 4 it has been suggested that the Superintending Engineer,
Punjab Water Supply and Sewerage Board, Bathinda circle
would visit the site personally and assess the cost of repair of
16 inch dia pipeline of Mandi Board already linked to carry
the sullage water of Abohar to the Abdul Khurana drain and
that necessary repairs would be carried out by the Municipal
Council, Abohar within a period of one month.
Mr. R.S. Bain, Local Commissioner, who also
attended the meeting in pursuance to the order dated 5.12.2011
has, however, pointed out that it may solve the problem only to
a limited extent of 30%. The size of the pipe is 16 inches
whereas minimum size of the pipe required is 48 inch.
Be that as it may, Mr. R.S. Bains shall submit his
report and any further progress made by visiting of the
Superintending Engineer, Punjab Water Supply and Sewerage
Board, Bathinda circle may also be placed on record before the
next date of hearing.
List again on 25.1.2012.
A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of
connected case.
Copy of the order be given to Mr. Suvir Sehgal,
Addl. A.G., Punjab under the signatures of the Court
Secretary."
;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.