JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) This application has been filed under Section 378(3) Cr. P. C.
seeking leave to file an appeal against judgment dated 1.10.2011 vide
which respondent No. 2 was acquitted of the charge framed against
him. Against accused No. 2, an FIR No. 269 was recorded on
29.7.2010, for commission of an offence punishable under Section
376 IPC, in Police Station Kotwali, District Patiala.
(2.) The process of law was initiated on a statement Ex. PA made
by the prosecutrix PW-1, stating that rape was committed upon her
without her consent on 12.6.2010 and thereafter, on 21.7.2010. The
trial Judge has recorded the following facts from the statement of the
Prosecutrix PW-1:-
"That she was a resident of Street No. 5, Peer Baba Range
Shah Colony, Sanaur Road, Patiala. She was residing in the
said house with her parents. Her parents were running the
business of Cable TV Operator. She herself educated upto
10+2. She alongwith her brother and sisters are three
siblings which including her sister and brother. Her elder
brother Ashwani Kumar was married. She being the next,
followed by her sister Aarti (married). She (the prosecutrix)
was married on 13.12.99 with one Pardeep Kumar son of
Bakhsha Ram, resident of Rajpura Town, from whom she
had two children, daughter aged about 8 years and the son
aged about 7 years. She got divorced from her husband in
the month of June, 2009. She was working as an Artist
with Orchestra Group. In the year 2006, she along with her
Orchestra Group had come to Noharia Mandir, Samania
Gate, Patiala to perform marriage function. A Bhangra
Group had also come to perform in the Wedding. One of
the members of the Bhangra Group was Gurjit Singh @
Sunny son of Karam Singh, resident of Babu Singh Colony,
Ablowal. She (the prosecutrix) happened to get acquainted
to said Gurjit Singh @ Sunny. Thereafter the acquaintance
turned into friendship and both of them kept on meeting
regularly. Eventually, the friendship turned into love
affairs. Gurjit Singh @ Sunny extended proposal for
marriage. The prosecutrix disclosed her antecedents that
she was married and divorced and had two children. Gurjit
Singh @ Sunny expressed that he had no problem and still
willing to marry. The prosecutrix moved this proposal to
her parents. Her parents were disagreement with this
proposal. Both of them i. e. the prosecutrix and the accused
Gurjit Singh jointly kept this proposal in front of the
parents. Even prior to the proposal, the prosecutrix and the
accused had become physical intimate with each other like
husband and wife. Ultimately, when the parents did not
exceed to their proposal, the prosecutrix and Gurjit Singh
proposed to get married on 31st May, 2009. Gurjit Singh
assured the prosecutrix that on 31.5.2009, somewhere
around 11 AM in the morning, he will send the car to
collect her. The prosecutrix made all the arrangements.
However, on 31.5.2009, neither Gurjit Singh nor the car
arrived to collect the prosecutrix. The prosecutrix tried her
level best to contact Gurjit Singh but his Mobile Phone
responded as switch off. In vain, the prosecutrix contacted
Manjit Singh, the brother of the accused Gurjit Singh, who
informed her that Gurjit Singh @ Sunny and their father
Karam Singh had gone out of station.
After about 10-12 days, the prosecutrix was
called up at the residence of Gurjit Singh @ Sunny on the
telephone, which was responded by the mother of the
accused. The mother of the accused had informed the
prosecutrix that Gurjit Singh was very much present at the
house and if she had any grudge, she could come to their
house and talk to Gurjit Singh. Upon that, the prosecutrix
arrived at the house of Gurjit singh, where Karam Singh,
his father and Sunita, his mother were present. The
prosecutrix confronted accused Gurjit Singh @ sunny as to
why he had ditched her. She confronted Gurjit Singh that
on his assurance, she had got divorce from her previous
husband and that now he had bagged out from the promise
of marriage, upon that heated arguments arose between the
parties. The prosecutrix consumed some tablets and
became unconscious. She was moved to Rajindera
Hospital, Patiala, where her parents also arrived. In the
presence of the parents, some compromise was affected and
it was agreed that prosecutrix and the accused would not
meet with each other in future.
On 12.6.2010, it was the birth day of the
prosecutrix. The accused was aware of this fact.
Somewhere around 2 AM i. e. mid night of 12/13.06.2010,
Gurjit Singh @ Sunny arrived at the house of the
prosecutrix and started knocking at her door. He prevailed
upon the prosecutrix to open the door. When the prosecutrix
resisted that she was unable to open the door because her
brother was present in the house. However, the accused
prevailed upon the prosecutrix and she opened the door,
upon which Gurjit Singh @ Sunny entered the room of the
prosecutrix and somehow prevailed upon her that he would
get married with her. The prosecutrix resisting by say that
mother is present in the house and she would raise the
alarm. The accused threatened the prosecutrix that is she
did so, he would injure her with a knife. According to the
prosecutrix, the accused put her under fear and without her
consent removed her clothes and committed sexual
intercourse with her and before leaving again threatened her
that if she reported the matter to any one, she would done to
death.
As a result, the prosecutrix became pregnant.
She contacted the accused on telephone and informed him
about the pregnancy. On 21.7.2010, the accused asked the
prosecutrix to come at the Bus Stand, Patiala, so that they
could find out some way. The prosecutrix accepted the
proposal and went to the Bus stand from where both of
them went to Kurukshetra on the assurance of the accused
that unwanted pregnancy could be terminated. Both of
them reached at Kurukshetra and stayed there for a night at
Jat Dharmashalla. On that night, the accused again forcibly
committed sexual intercourse with the prosecutrix, but
failed to get the pregnancy terminated. On 22.7.2010, some
where about 2/2.30 PM, the prosecutrix informed about all
these developments to her mother on telephone. She told
her mother that Gurjit Singh @ Sunny had fraudulently on
the basis of certain assurance brought her to Kurukshetra.
In the meanwhile, the brother of the accused called him on
the telephone and informed that the local police looking
after him. Upon that the accused along with prosecutrix left
Kurukshetra for Patiala. When they arrived at Patiala, she
went to her parents' house. On 29.7.2010, she complained
the matter to the police. "
(3.) After recording statement of the prosecutrix, the
Investigating Officer got her medically examined from Dr. Daljit
Kaur PW-3. Accused was arrested and after recording statements of
other witnesses, final report was put in Court for trial. Copies of the
documents were supplied to the accused-respondent No. 2 as per
norms and vide order dated 6.1.2011 the case was committed to the
competent Court for adjudication. The accused was charge sheeted to
which he pleaded not guilty and claimed trial. The prosecution
produced 7 witnesses and also brought on record documentary
evidence to prove its case.;