JUDGEMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL,J. -
(1.) Through this judgment, 32 Civil Writ Petitions bearing no.4342, 4421, 4362, 4380, 4381, 12647, 4554, 4567, 4604, 5215, 5721, 5723, 5758, 5788, 5319, 6180, 14479, 14599, 14603, 14622, 14679, 14879, 14486, 14488, 14758, 14770, 14780, 14899, 14492, 14496, 14539, 14952 of 2020, shall stand disposed of. Out of the above referred 32 writ petitions, 16 writ petitions have been filed by the workmen, whereas the remaining have been filed by the management-Punjab Financial Corporation, challenging identical awards passed in all the writ petitions by the Industrial Tribunal, Patiala (hereinafter referred to as 'the tribunal').
Municipal Council, Dina Nagar vs. Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Gurdaspur and another,2014 70 RCR(Civ) 119
(2.) Detailed particulars of the petitioners, their date of joining, date of dismissal, salary/emoluments, years of service, as well as compensation awarded has been compiled in a tabulated form which is as under:-
Sr.
No
CWP
No.
Title
Salary/
emoluments
Date of
joining
Date of
Dismissal
Years of
service
Compensation
awarded.
1
4342/2020
Sharma
Ram
Rs.13,110/-
23.09.1985
29.11.2011
26 years 2
months
Rs.8000/- per
year of
service
2
4362/2020
Prem Chand
Rs.13,110/-
11.01.1988
29.11.2011
23 years 10
months 19
days
Rs.8000/- per
year of service
3
4380/2020
Kesar Singh
Rs.13,110/-
05.02.1988
29.11.2011
23 years 09
months 25
days
Rs.8000/- per
year of
service
4
4381/2020
Sukhwant Singh
Rs.13,110/-
16.01.1988
29.11.2011
23 years 10
months 14
days
Rs.8000/- per
year of
service
5
4421/2020
Madan Gopal
Rs.13,110/-
25.05.1988
29.11.2011
23 years 06
months 5
days
Rs.8000/- per
year of
service
6
4554/2020
Harchand Singh
Rs.13,110/-
27.03.1987
29.11.2011
24 years 08
months 29
days
Rs.8000/- per
year of
service
7
4567/2020
Shamsher Singh
Rs.13,110/-
03.01.1987
29.11.2011
24 years 10
months 27
days
Rs.8000/- per
year of
service
8
4604/2020
Nirmal Singh
Rs.13,110/-
27.12.1984
29.11.2011
26 years 11
months 3
days
Rs.8000/- per
year of
service
9
12647/2020
Ram Pal Deceased
through
LRs
Rs,2,650/-
26.05.1988
29.11.2011
23 years 06
months
Rs.8000/- per
year of
service
10
5215/2020
Satpal
Rs,2,650/-
02.07.1993
20.08.2002
09 years 02
months
Rs.5000/- per
year of
service
11
5319/2020
Gurcharan Singh
Rs,2,650/-
19.03.1994
17.02.1999
04 years 11
months
Rs.5000/- per
year of
service
12
5721/2020
Ram Sarup
Rs,2,650/-
29.03.1993
27.07.2002
09 years 04
months
Rs.5000/- per
year of
service
13
5723/2020
Ram Kumar
Rs,2,650/-
23.11.1993
01.04.2002
08 years 06
months
Rs.5000/- per
year of
service
14
5758/2020
Malkiat Singh
Rs,2,650/-
11.04.1994
20.08.2002
08 years 06
months
Rs.5000/- per
year of
service
15
5788/2020
Sudagar Gir
Rs,2,650/-
29.03.1993
20.08.2002
09 years 05
months
Rs.5000/- per
year of
service
16
6180/2020
Kirpal Singh
Rs,2,650/-
18.04.1994
27.07.2002
08 years 03
months
Rs.5000/- per
year of
service
(3.) As noticed in the tabulated information, the Tribunal has awarded compensation in lieu of reinstatement. The workmen have filed these writ petitions claiming that they are entitled to reinstatement or in the alternative for grant of appropriate compensation for illegal termination of their services.;