FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA Vs. FRIENDS RICE MILLS
LAWS(P&H)-2011-3-976
HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
Decided on March 04,2011

FOOD CORPORATION OF INDIA Appellant
VERSUS
FRIENDS RICE MILLS Respondents

JUDGEMENT

- (1.) Vide this judgment both these appeals will be disposed of as these have arisen out of the same suit.
(2.) Plaintiff Food Corporation of India (FCI for short) filed a suit for recovery against the rice mill-Defendant.
(3.) The case of the FCI, in brief, was that a policy had been framed by the Central Government and under the said policy, the FCI used to purchase paddy from the market and give it to the millers for shelling. Defendant-mill had agreed to shell the paddy as per its storage capacity. The paddy stored under the mill was to remain in joint custody of the FCI and the mill. As per the policy of the Central Government, 67 % of superfine rice was required to be delivered out of the paddy supplied to the Defendant. The Defendant had agreed to abide by the terms and conditions of the said agreement. The Defendant had furnished the requisite security in terms of the agreement. The Defendant was also responsible for the safe custody of paddy supplied to it for milling and delivery of rice as per the agreement. Losses, if any, incurred during the transit or storage were to be made good by the Defendant @ 1 time of economic costs of the variety of paddy/rice. The Defendant was required to deliver the rice within ten days of issuance of supply of paddy at regular intervals. As per schedule, 20% of rice was to be delivered in the months of October/November 1994, 26% in December 1994, 26% in the month of January 1995 and 28% in the month of February 1995. The Defendant had, however, failed to shell the paddy and as such it becomes liable to pay 1 time of economic costs of paddy supplied to it. The total paddy stored in the premises of the Defendant was 21760 bags weighing 14140.10 quintals of superfine paddy. Since the Defendant had failed to shell the paddy, the Defendant dispatched 7840 bags weighing 4881.80 quintals of paddy before 31.5.1995. Cost of the remaining paddy was assessed at Rs. 876.21 per quintal @ 1 time of the economic cost i.e. Rs. 81,12,215/- on 1.6.1995. Out of remaining paddy, 13952 bags were retrieved and their value was assessed at Rs. 395/- per quintal weighing 8590.08 quintals amounting to Rs. 33,93,082/-. The FCI was entitled to recover Rs. 47,19,113/- from the Defendant. An expenditure of Rs. 83,712/- was incurred by the FCI for retrieving the paddy and hence, the FCI was entitled to recover Rs. 48,02,825 plus 22,33,312/- towards interest.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.