RANOTOSH SAHA Vs. SECRETARY GOVERNMENT OF WEST BENGAL
LAWS(CAL)-2007-5-37
HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA
Decided on May 18,2007

RANOTOSH SAHA Appellant
VERSUS
SECRETARY GOVERNMENT OF WEST BENGAL Respondents

JUDGEMENT

- (1.) A show-cause notice dated 15. 11. 2002, issued by the Chairperson, kaliaganj Municipality has been subjected to challenge in the present writ proceeding at the instance of the petitioner who, at the material time, was working in the said Municipality as an Assignment Inspector. The petitioner was sought to be proceeded against for committing misconduct of temporary defalcation of public fund, insubordination and for raising incorrect and inconsistent pleas for obtaining leave on medical ground.
(2.) THE show-cause notice was challenged not on the ground that the Chairperson had no authority to issue the same or that the" same did not disclose any offence or that the allegations were vague. On the contrary, the same was assailed on the ground that before initiation of disciplinary, proceeding against the petitioner, a First Information Report had been lodged on 3. 7. 02 in relation to an allegation of defalcation of fund by the petitioner, giving rise to Kaliaganj Police Station Case no. 84/02 dated 3. 7. 02 under Section 409 of the Indian Penal Code and since criminal proceeding was pending on the charge of temporary defalcation alleged against the petitioner in the show-cause notice, the continuation of parallel proceedings, viz. criminal proceeding and departmental proceeding would compel the petitioner to disclose his defence which ultimately would prejudicially affect him in the criminal proceeding. In the writ petition, the relief sought for is as follows:- (a) To issue a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the respondents, namely, respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 to keep the departmental proceeding initiated on the basis of charge-sheet dated 15. 11. 2002 issued by the Chairman, Kaliaganj Municipality in abeyance till the disposal of the criminal case being Kaliaganj P. S. Case No. 84/02 dated 03. 07. 2002 (G. R. Case No. 380/02), now pending before the learned Sub-Divisional Judicial Magistrate, raiganj, and/or (b) To issue a writ in the nature of certiorary calling upon the respondents to transmit and produce the record of the case at the time of hearing of this application, so that conscionable justice may be administered to the petitioner upon perusal thereof.
(3.) THE writ petition was heard on 24. 1. 2003. Though they were put on notice, the Municipal authorities did not appear. The departmental proceeding initiated against the petitioner was stayed for a limited period. Thereafter, on 19. 2. 2003 the writ petition was admitted when the Municipal authorities again chose not to be represented and the interim order was extended until further orders. It is not disputed that in compliance with the interim order passed by this Court, the respondents did not proceed with the disciplinary proceeding against the petitioner.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.