JUDGEMENT
Ganguly, J. -
(1.) This Public Interest Litigation has been filed by Asian
Village Society (hrerinafter called the petitioner), a Society registered under
the West Bengal Societies Registration Act, challenging, inter alia, the decision
of the Excise Authorities to allow the manufacturers of Indian Made Foreign
Liquor (IMFL) to sell liquor in recycled bottles. In the writ petition the petitioner,
has described itself as a non-Goyernment self-dependent educational and
Technological Service Organisation with a spirit for public welfare. It has also
been stated that the petitioner filed the Public Interest Litigation in the interest
of consumers of IMFL as such consumers are unaware of the quality of bottles
used by IMFL manufacturers. As such, the consumers of IMFL very often
contact diseases by consuming liquor from such bottles. In a civilised society
it is necessary to protect the interest of the members of the public who are
unaware of the dangers involved in the reuse of old bottles. It has also been
stated that the petitioner has no personal interest and the Public Interest
Litigation has been filed in the interest of public who cannot individually come
and ventilate their grievances. These averments have been made in Paragraphs
35 and 37 of the writ petition justifying the filing of the Public Interest Litigation,
(2.) The basic facts in this case are as follows :-
By a Notification dated 21st January, 2003 published in the
Official Gazette it was stated that all IMFL manufacturers shall use
new bottles for IMFL and it appears from the affidavit of the Excise
Commissioner that the said order was issued in public interest.
Thereafter, the said Notification dated 21st January, 2003 was kept
under suspension by a subsequent order dated 27th July, 2003 and
such suspension has been continued from time of time. Ultimately
by an order dated 8th March, 2005, which has been issued by the
Excise Department, Government of West Bengal, it has been ordered
that the initial Notification dated 21st January, 2003 shall remain
suspended until further orders. It was also stated by the Government
Order dated 8th March, 2005 that the previous Government Orders
dated 29th July, 2003 and 26th March, 2004 are ratified.
(3.) The subject-matter of challenge in this Public Interest Litigation
is the correctness or legality of the subsequent orders dated 29th July,
2003 and 26th March, 2004 as also 8th March, 2005 by which the initial
order of 21st January, 2003 has been suspended.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.