JUDGEMENT
Pinaki Chandra Ghose, J. -
(1.) The suit and the interlocutory application have been filed by the
petitioner for restraining the respondents from -
(i) infringing the registered design No. 165256 of the petitioner in respect of bottles.
A copy of the said registration is at page 15 of the petition.
(ii) passing off its products and/or business as that of the petitioner by using the
shape, configuration, size and get-up of the containers/bottles.
(2.) Both the petitioner and the respondent No. 1 are manufacturing shampoos and
other cosmetics items. The petitioner sells its products under its mark 'Ayur'. The
respondent No. 1 sells its products under its own mark 'Coronation'. The range of
the petitioner's products in bottles of its registered design is at page 13 of the
petition. The range of the products of the respondent No. 1 in its own bottles will
appear from annexure appearing at page 54 of the petition.
(3.) According to the petitioner, the petitioner is engaged in the business of
manufacture and marketing of cosmetics, shampoos and lotions since about the
year 1984. According to the petitioner, the petitioner developed a new design of the
containers/bottles for its aforesaid shampoos and lotions bearing the trademark
AYUR in or about beginning of the year 1993. The petitioner duly obtained the
registration in respect of the said design in or about 2nd February, 1993 and started
selling its products in containers bearing the registered design from 1993 onwards.
According to the petitioner, it acquires substantial reputation and goodwill in the
cosmetics market. In April, 1998 the petitioner learnt that the respondent No. 1
selling shampoos and lotions in containers bearing a design identical to that of the
petitioner. The petitioner duly instituted proceedings for infringement of its registered
design against the defendants before the Delhi High Court which is pending.
Subsequently, the petitioner came to learn that the defendant had obtained
registration of the said design. The petitioner had filed application before the Delhi
High Court which is also pending.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.