JUDGEMENT
R.K.Mahajan, J. -
(1.) The petitioner has sought the following reliefs through this writ petition:
"(i) issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari quashing the order dated 16.7.1986
passed by the Chancellor respondent No. 1 as contained in Annexure '8' to this writ petition;
(ii) issue a writ, order of direction in the nature of mandamuss directing the respondents not to
interfere with the petitioner's functioning as Lecturer in Rig-Veda.
(iii) issue any other writ, order or direction as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper under
the circumstances of the case; and (iv) to award costs."
(2.) This writ petition is coming up for hearing after the petitioner obtained a stay order on 23rd
August, 1986 by which the operation of order of Chancellor dated 15.7.1986 was stayed by
virtue of which petitioner's appointment as a Lecturer in Rig-Veda in the Sampurnanand Sanskrit
Vishvavidyalaya was found to be illegal as he lacked basic qualification and also on other
grounds which are of vital importance i.e. the petitioner's application was entertained much after
the lapse of last date mentioned in the advertisement and he was also selected through a back
door entry. The Chancellor gave a direction to the University to make fresh appointment after
readvertisement of the post. In this writ petition two questions are to be considered. What is the
effect of entertaining the application of the petitioner after the advertisement date has been
issued and selecting him without readvertising the post in all fairness and not complying with the
provisions-of Article 14 of Constitution of India for not giving a chance to the candidates who
were qualified for consideration.
(3.) There is Sampurnanand Sanskrit Vishvavidyalaya (hereinafter referred to as the
Vishvavidyalaya) in Varanasi. It appears that the said Vishvavidyalaya; advertised a post of
Lecturer in Rig-Veda. Provision of Statute 11.01 of the Statute of Vishvavidyalaya is quoted
here for ready reference:
"11.01. In case of the Faculties of Veda- Vedanga, Sahitya - Sanskrit, Darshan Shraman Vidya
and Adhunik Jnana- Vijnana, the following shall be the minimum qualifications for the post of
Lecturer in the University, namely
(a) A doctorate in the subject of study, concerned or a published work of a high standard in that
subjected
(b) Consistently good academic record (that is to say (the overall record of all assessment
throughout the academic career of a candidate), with first class or high second class ( that is to
say, with an aggregate of more than 54 percent marks ) Master's Degree in the subject concerned
or equivalent degree of a foreign university in such subject.
2. Where the Selection Committee is of opinion that the research work of: a candidate, as
evidenced either by his thesis or by his published work, is of a very high standard, it may relax
any of the requirements specified in Sub-clause (b) of Clause (1).
3. If a candidate possessing a qualification prescribed in Sub-clause (a) of Clause (1) is not
available or is not considered suitable a person possessing a consistently good academic record
(Due weightance being given to M. Phil, or equivalent degree or research work of quality) may
be appointed in the condition that he will attain the prescribed qualification (namely doctorate or
published work aforesaid) withing five years, from the date of his appointment; provided that
where, the teacher so appointed fails to attain the prescribed qualification within the said period
of five years, he shall not be entitled to yearly' comments after such period, until he attains such
qualifications.";
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.