COMMISSIONER OF WEALTH TAX Vs. RAM NARAIN GARG
LAWS(ALL)-1987-10-46
HIGH COURT OF ALLAHABAD
Decided on October 29,1987

COMMISSIONER OF WEALTH TAX Appellant
VERSUS
RAM NARAIN GARG* Respondents

JUDGEMENT

OM PRAKASH, J. - (1.) AT the instance of the CWT, Kanpur, as many as 7 References have been made by the IT Tribunal seeking our opinion on a common question; whether or not reversionary value can be added to the value of the building arrived at rent capitalisation method.
(2.) WHEREAS , the WTO was of the view that the reversionary value was to be added, the Tribunal took a contrary view that the reversionary value was not to be added. As in all the References, the question referred to this Court is not only similar but identical, we dispose of all the References by a common order.
(3.) THE question whether or not reversionary value is to be added to the value of the building arrived at by having followed the rent capitalisation method, is not res integro. So far as this Court is concerned, a similar question came up for hearing before this Court very recently in CWT, Kanpur vs. Ram Saran Kajriwal (1987) 64 CTR (All) 32 : (1987) 168 ITR 485 (All) and then this Court took the view that the reversionary value will not be added to the value of the building determined on rent capitalisation method.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.