JUDGEMENT
Amitava Lala, J. -
(1.) The writ petitioners made this petition for the purpose of quashing of the Government Order dated 4.1.2001 so far as it relates to condition No. 1, order dated 6.9.2000 and order dated 13.5.2000. They have further prayed that respondents and their subordinates be directed not to interfere with the right of the petitioners to transport High Speed Diesel Oil from retail outlet to their business premises by utilising services of the oil tankers as per Form IX prescribed under the Petroleum Rules, 1976. Conditions under Form IX are as follows:
(i) Transportation of High Speed Diesel Oil through a tanker holding a licence in Form IX under the Petroleum Rules, is very safe as these licences are issued only after certificates are issued by the Agni Shaman Adhikari (i.e. Fire Prevention Officer).
(ii) Transportation price is lesser in case of transportation by these tankers as compared to that of tractor trolleys.
(iii) Contents of the tankers are insured whereas in case of tractor trolleys every time this is not so.
(iv) That there is calibration of Oil contents in a tanker which is not so in case of diesel oil being transported by any other mode.
(v) That a fire extinguisher of a prescribed specification is always there (as per condition No.1 of the licence) in case of transport by a tanker.
(vi) That every safety measures are there on the tankers in terms of conditions No. 4(b), 4(c) and other conditions also.
(2.) In May, 2000 a petty dealer was victim of serious out break of fire, as a result whereof State Government placed certain restrictions to the petty dealers. Such conditions are available in Annexure - 8 to the writ petition. No such condition as regard transportation of High Speed Diesel by the oil tanker was made. Several writ petitions were made by various writ petitioners but the purpose of making such writ petitions are not germane for due consideration. However, Government has passed an order dated 4.1.2001 restricting the petitioners and other licensee like them from utilising services of oil tanker for transportation of High Speed Diesel Oil from retail outlet to their business premises. According to the petitioners, such restrictions are clear interference with the right of the petitioners guaranteed under Article 19(1 )(g) read with Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
(3.) In 1981 the U.P. High Speed Diesel Oil and Light Diesel Oil (Maintenance of Supplies and Distribution) Order, 1981 came into force in exercise of the powers under Section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, 1955 read with Governmental Order dated 30th November, 1974. In the said order 1981 different meanings are given defining the meaning "d" "dealer", "I" "retailer" and "n" "wholesaler" "dealer" means a person engaged in the business of purchase, sale or storage for sale of High Speed Diesel Oil or Light Diesel Oil but does not include an Oil Company; "retailer" means a dealer who is not a wholesaler; "wholesaler" means in the case of Light Diesel Oil means a dealer who deals in light diesel oil exceeding 100 litres in a single transaction and in the case of High Speed Diesel Oil a dealer who sells High Speed Diesel Oil by means of dispensing pumps. Apart from such three categories the other category is "oil company". Oil Company means the company below:
(1) Indian Oil Corporation Ltd.
(2) Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd.
(3) Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.
(4) The Indo-Burmah Petroleum Company Ltd.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.