JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) The petitioner, Dr.Rajendra Singh, a Medical Officer with the
PMHS, feeling aggrieved by his transfer order dated 29.6.04 transferring
him from World Bank Project, Jhansi as Deputy C.M.O., Banda, has filed a
second writ petition challenging the same very order of transfer. Earlier
Writ Petition No.889 (SB) of 2004 was filed by him challenging the
aforesaid transfer order, which was dismissed by a Division Bench of this
court, vide order dated 31.8.2004 after finding that there was no illegality
in the transfer order with the clarification that this order would not come in
the way in deciding the representation of the petitioner. Thereafter it
appears that the petitioner filed a review petition against the aforesaid
order, 9which was also dismissed, vide order dated 10.9.04. After being
unsuccessful in challenging the transfer order and having met with failure
in the writ petition and also in the review petition, this second writ petition
has again been filed challenging the same very transfer order.
(2.) Dr. Rajendra Singh, who appears in person, in support of his case
submitted that since various pleas could not be taken in the earlier writ
petition, therefore, this writ petition has been filed.
The prayer in this writ petition is also for issuing a direction for
deciding the representation made by the petitioner against the transfer order
and for quashing the transfer order dated 29.6.2004.
The petitioner having already filed one writ petition challenging the
transfer order dated 29.6.2004 cannot be allowed to challenge the same
order by filing another writ petition. The earlier writ petition was
dismissed on merits and the review petition has also been rejected. In these
circumstances, a second writ petition challenging the transfer order is not
maintainable and cannot be entertained.
(3.) The petitioner also raised a grievance, that WHO Fellowship in
Thailand has been granted to him but the State Government is not giving
'No Objection Certificate' and, therefore, the prayer is that a direction be
issued to the State Government to grant 'No Objection Certificate' to the
petitioner. In the writ petition there is no such prayer but only orally it has
been urged by the petitioner. Since no such relief has been claimed in the
writ petition, we cannot entertain this plea and no such interim relief can be
granted. However, it will be open to the petitioner to pursue his case before
the State Government, as per rules, for seeking 'No Objection'.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.