JUDGEMENT
Vincet Saran, J. -
(1.) The short question
to be determined by this Court in this writ petition is
as to whether the Trial Court as well
as Revisional Court were justified in rejecting
the application of the petitioners for taking certain
additional documents on record after 18
years of the filing of the written statement and
framing of issues; and after the evidence of
the plaintiff had already been closed.
(2.) The brief facts are that the respondent
No. 3 Smt. Kesar Sharma, who is the owner
of the property in dispute, filed suit No. 202
of 1983 against one Jagan Lal (which was the
tenant of the property in question) for arrears
of rent and eviction from the property in question.
The said Jagan Lal contested the suit and
filed his written statement on 21-5-1985. The
issues had already been framed for the determination
of the Court. During the pendency
of the case, in August, 1985, said Jagan Lal
expired and the names of the petitioners were
substituted in his place. The evidence of the
plaintiff-respondent No. 3 was closed by the
Trial Court on 2-7-2003. On the next date,
which was 31-7-2003, the defendant-petitioner
filed an application, purported to be under
Section 151, C.P.C. praying for accepting certain
additional documents in evidence. The said
application of the petitioners has been rejected
by a detailed order dated 31-7-2003 passed
by the Trial Court. The petitioners preferred a
revision against the said order, which has also
been dismissed by the Additional District Judge,
Khurja, Bulandshahar on 13-10-2004. Aggrieved
by the said orders, the petitioners have
filed this writ petition.
(3.) I have heard Sri V.K. Birla, learned
Counsel for the petitioners as well as Sri Vinod
Sinha, learned Counsel for the contesting respondent
No. 3 and have perused the record.
Counter and rejoinder affidavits have already
been exchanged and with consent of the
learned Counsel for the parties, this writ petition
is being disposed of at the admission stage
itself.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.