JUDGEMENT
BHALLA, J. -
(1.) By this writ petition under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India the Petitioners' Firm, who is engaged in supply
of meat groups items to the Military Stations
seeks issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari, for quashing of the order dated 21-4-2003, contained in Annexure-1, whereby the name of the petitioner-firm has been removed from the approved list of ASC contractors and also prayed for a writ or direction in the'nature of mandamus to the opposite parties not to treat the petitioner firm as an un-registered ASC firm.
(2.) M/s. Quality Traders has questioned the correctness and validity of. the order dated 21-4-2003 passed by the Major General,
MG ASC by means of which the name of the petitioner firm has been removed from the approved list of Army Supply Corps Contractors
primarily on the ground that the impugned order has been passed in blatant disregard of the principles of natural justice;
the procedure as prescribed under Regulation 26 was not followed before
removing the petitioner and the decision to remove the name of the petitioner firm had already been taken and implemented prior to issuance of show cause notice as on 9-1-2003
and 4-2-2003 when the petitioner firm was found to be lowest tenderer, it was not awarded the contract. In addition to above, the petitioner firm was not allowed to participate
in re-tendering process in respect of the Lucknow, Gwalior and Meerut stations which the petitioner Firm was the lowest
tenderer.
(3.) According to the learned Counsel for the petitioner the impugned order dated 21 -4-2003
is against the principles of natural justice, as the decision was taken prior to issuance of show cause notice and the procedure
as prescribed under Regulation 26 was not followed before removing the petitioner.
The fact that authorities were predetermined
to remove the petitioner from the list of approved ASC contractors and the issuance of show cause notice dated 26-3-2003
was sham, is proved from the averments
made in the short counter affidavit filed on 17-4-2003 by an Officer of Central Command in writ petition No. 1941 (MB) of 2003 (M/s. Quality Traders v. Union of India
and others) wherein it has been mentioned
"that a decision was taken not to enter
into any business / transactions with M/s. Quality Traders for the supply of meat group items in future and to disassociate with erring
firm M/s. Quality Traders.";
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.