JUDGEMENT
M.Katju, J. -
(1.) By means of this writ petition the petitioner
has challenged the impugned order dated 21-5-2003 (Annexure-7
to the petition). By that order, it has been held
that petitioner Nanku is a Muslim Nut by caste
and is not a Hindu Nut by caste, and consequently his caste certificate has been cancelled.
(2.) It may be mentioned that Hindu Nut
has been declared to be a Scheduled caste by
the State of U.P. as stated in para 10 of the
petition. The petitioner contested the election
of Gram Pradhan of Gram Panchayat Atwa
Chechari which is reserved for Scheduled
Caste. He received 424 votes while his main
opponent Chandra Pal received 301 votes, and
hence the petitioner was declared successful.
The main contestant Chandra Pal who was
defeated by 123 votes made a complaint on
25-4-2000 before the District Magistrate
Moradabad stating that the petitioner is a Muslim Nut by caste and he has forged a caste
certificate for the purposes of election. On the
basis of that application, the A.D.M.,
Moradabad appointed the Sub-Divisional Magistrate and
Tehshildar, Bilari as Inquiry
Officers on 30-5-2000. The Tehsildar, Bilari submitted his report dated 30-5-2000 vide
Annexure 4. On 9-8-2000 the S.D.M.
Chandausi submitted his report to the D.M.
vide Annexure-5 to the petition. It was held
therein that the petitioner is a Muslim Nut and
has obtained .false caste certificate by committing fraud.
Petitioner filed a writ petition in this
Court, which is still pending. However, by the
impugned order dated 21-5-2003, the petitioner's caste certificate has been cancelled.
(3.) Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the petitioner has not been given
any opportunity of hearing. We do not agree
with the submission. A perusal of the report of
the Tehsildar vide Annexure-4 shows that the
petitioner has produced the documents before
the Inquiry Officer. A persual of para 5 of the
impugned order dated 21-5-2003 shows that
the petitioner Nanku gave a statement before
the Authority and he admitted that his mother's name is Shahzadi and his father has been
buried in a graveyard. The finding of fact is
that the petitioner is a Muslim Nut by caste
and is not a Hindu Nut by caste. We cannot
interfere with the same in writ jurisdiction.
The petition is accordingly dismissed.
Petition dismissed.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.