JUDGEMENT
S.K.Dhaon, J. -
(1.) In this and the companion Writ Petition Nos. 8214 of 1986,3294 of 1985,13015 of 1984 and
9948 of 1983 the employers feel aggrieved by the refusal of the State of Uttar Pradesh to accord
them permission to close down either undertakings or units.
(2.) In this petition the material averments of Jay Shree Tea and Industries Ltd., a public limited
company, are these. Amongst other businesses, the company has an establishment of Jay Shree
Tyres and Rubber Products at Allahabad (hereinafter referred to as the Allahabad Unit). Each
business run by the company is a separate establishment having a separate finance, management
and control. The Allahabad unit has been suffering huge losses year after year. It has suffered
losses from its very inception. In 1976-77 its loss was of Rs. 1.68 lacs, in 1977-78 the loss was
of Rs. 49.98 lacs, in 1978-79 the loss was of Rs. 44.37 lacs, in 1979-80 the loss was Rs. 92.08
lacs, in 1980-81 the loss was of Rs 114.5 lacs, in 1981-82 the loss was of Rs. 110.15 lacs, in
1982-83 the loss was of Rs. 109.65 lacs, in 1983-84 the loss was of Rs. 133.55 lacs, in 1984-85
the loss was of Rs. 164.25 lacs and in 1985-86 the loss was of Rs. 195.91 lacs. The total loss
suffered is of Rs. 1,022.17 lacs. On September 29,1986, the State Government re jected the
application, dated August 4, 1986 seeking permission to close down the unit. Upon an
application for review made by the petitioner, the State Government referred the matter for
adjudication to a Tribunal and on February 26, 1987, the Tribunal passed an award maintaining
the order of the State Government.
(3.) In Writ Petition No. 8214 of 1986 M/s Amitabh Textile Mills Limited is the petitioner. The
material averments are these. The petitioner has been suffering heavy losses for last few years
and is one of the sick units in textile in Northern India. There is no possibility of improvement in
the foreseeable future. On August 7, 1985, the State Government declined to grant the
permission to close down its factory. The prayer made by the petitioner for review of its order
was not acceded to by the State Government. However, it made a reference to a Tribunal which
on March 6, 1986 passed an award maintaining the order of the State Government.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.