- (1.) Following the decision in Civil Nos. 8479-8482 of 1994 (United Breweries Ltd. v. State of A. P. ) , these appeals must fail.
(2.) Mr. B. Sen, appearing on behalf of the respondents has drawn our attention to clause (ff) of sub-rule (4 of Rule 6 of the Karnataka Sales Tax Rules, 1957, which specifically provides: "6.(4 In determining the taxable turnover, the amount specified in clauses (a) to (n) shall, subject to the conditions specified therein, be deducted from the total turnover as determined under clauses (a) to (e) of sub-rule (1- (a) to (f) * * * (ff) all amounts falling under the head charges for packing; that is to say, the cost of packing materials and cost of labour for packing in respect of goods not liable to tax at the hands of the assessee, whether or not such amounts are specified and charged for by the dealer separately;"
(3.) Mr. B. Sen has contended that this is an additional ground why appeals should be dismissed in this case.;