STATE OF RAJASTHAN Vs. H V HOTELS PVT LTD
LAWS(SC)-2007-1-57
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA (FROM: RAJASTHAN)
Decided on January 12,2007

STATE OF RAJASTHAN Appellant
VERSUS
H.V.HOTELS PVT. LTD. Respondents

JUDGEMENT

- (1.) Leave granted.
(2.) The Government of Rajasthan issued a public notice advertising sale by auction of a plot of land measuring 10,490 square metres. The purchaser was to use the plot for construction of a hotel. The auction took place on 14.2.1996. The first respondent, acting through its Director, the second Respondent, entered the highest bid. The said bid was accepted. The bid amount was deposited by the respondent on 4.5.1996. The State of Rajasthan the appellant herein, executed a sale deed in favour of the second respondent in his capacity as the Director of the first respondent on 26.3.1997. The sale deed stipulated that out of the total extent, an extent of 1,510 square metres will be surrendered by the purchaser free of cost for widening of an existing road and that the purchaser will be given the benefit of the floor area ratio calculated on the basis of the original plot size of 10,490 square metres. The parameters of construction were set out and the floor area ratio was given as 1.0. There was also a stipulation that consequent upon any change in Building bye-laws framed by the local authorities including the Jaipur Development Authority, if the buyer got additional floor area ratio or any relaxation, the State would have no objection, so long as the same are permitted by the bye-laws prevailing from time to time.
(3.) Possession was delivered to the purchaser on 26.7.2000. According to the purchaser, there was a shortage of 263 square metres in the area. The purchaser, therefore, applied to the Government for redressal of his grievance regarding the shortage in extent. On 22.3.2000, the Government agreed to adjust the said extent of 263 square metres as against 1,510 square metres the purchaser had to surrender free of charge for the widening of the road. On 17.8.2001, the purchaser sought permission to change the user of the land and for permission to construct a multi purpose commercial complex and multi complex instead of a hotel. On 27.11.2001, permission for such changed user was given by the State.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.