JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) Leave granted in both the Special Leave Petitions.
(2.) Appellants herein are owners of various tracts of agricultural lands
situate in Village Chak Gujran, Tehsil and District Hoshiarpur in the State of
Punjab. Respondent No. 5, M/s International Tractors Limited, is a
Company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956. It intended to set up
a project named "Ganesha Project". It requested the State to acquire lands in
question in terms of the provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for
short, "the Act"). A notification was issued by the State purported to be
under Section 4 of the Act on 15.02.2002, stating :
"Whereas it appears to the Governor of Punjab that
Land is likely to be required to be taken by the
Government at the public expense, for a public purpose
namely for setting up of Ganesha Project, M/s.
International Tractors Ltd. at Village Chak Gujran, Tehsil
& Distt. Hoshiarpur, it is hereby notified that the land in
locality described below is likely to be required for the
above purpose.
This notification is made under the provisions of
Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 to all whom
it may concern.
In exercise of powers conferred by the aforesaid
section, the Governor of Punjab is pleased to authorize
the officers for the time being engaged in undertaking
with their servants and workmen to enter upon and
survey any land in the locality and do all other acts
required or permitted by that section.
Any person interest who has any objection to the
acquisition of any land in the locality may within thirty
days of the publication of this notification file an
objection in writing before the Collector, Land
Acquisition Department of Industries & Commerce,
Punjab, 17-Bays Building, Chandigarh."
(3.) Objections having been called for, the appellants herein filed their
objections in terms of Section 5A of the Act, inter alia, stating :
"5. That the proposed acquisition by the Punjab
Government is unconstitutional, uncalled for and
against law and fact of the case, just in order to
cause loss to the objectors and to give unlawful
gain to other party, i.e., the proposed "Ganesha
Projectors M/s. International Tractor Ltd.
7. That the acquisition of the proposed land
belonging to the objectors is against the interest of
the objectors keeping in view the policies of the
State. The land in question is cultivable fertile
land and the proposed project if any can be shifted
some where else at some barren land as well as in
the industrial zone according to Industries Master
Plan and in this way, it is in the interest of the
Pollution Control Department.
9. That the objectors are cultivating the land for the
last over 25 years, it is consolidated at one place
where in the objector has installed electric motors
and planted popular trees around the fields. The
objectors do not want that the land in question be
acquired since it is against their interest and
objectors are dependent on this Acquisition land.
The Agriculturist/Farmer is entirely dependent on
his land for his livelihood. There are various
projects in the name of Escorts Tractors, Mohindra
Tractors, Massy Furgon Tractors and so many
other tractors companies/industries fulfilling the
needs of the public and as such there is no need at
all of the proposed industry to be set up in the
lands of the objectors.
10. That in any way the proposed acquisition is against
the rules of the acquisition and the act itself
keeping in view the interest of the objectors thus
causing wrongful loss to the objectors and causing
wrongful gain to the proposed objectors.";
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.