JUDGEMENT
RANJAN GOGOI, J. -
(1.)THE petitioner is a leading orthopaedic surgeon of the country and the Chairman and Head of the Department of Orthopaedic Surgery in the Ganga
Hospital at Coimbatore. He was/is also the President of the Indian
Orthopaedic Association, the largest professional body of orthopaedic
surgeons in the country. In the course of his professional duties
spanning over several decades the petitioner, while rendering
professional service to victims of road accidents, has come to realise
that the large number of accidents that occur every day on the Indian
roads, causing loss of human lives besides loss of limbs and other
injuries resulting in human tragedies, are wholly avoidable. In the light
of the experience gained and propelled by a desire to render service
beyond the call of duty, the petitioner has filed this writ petition
under Article 32 of the Constitution seeking the Court 's intervention,
primarily, in the matter of enforcement of the prevailing laws and also
seeking directions for enactment of what the petitioner considers to be
more appropriate legislative measures and for more affirmative
administrative action. The petitioner also seeks directions from the
Court for upliftment of the existing infrastructure and facilities with
regard to post -accident care and management to minimize loss of life and
physical injuries to victims of road accidents.
(2.)IN the context of the aforesaid effort, the petitioner has set out detailed statistics published by the Ministry of Road Transport and
Highways (MoRTH) in the volume ''Road Accidents in India 2010 ''
highlighting the extent of increase of road accidents and fatal cases
between 1970 -2010.
In the aforesaid publication in which the relevant figures are pegged to
the year 2010 it is reported that road traffic accidents in the said year
i.e. 2010 numbered nearly 5,00,000 resulting in approximately 1,30,000
deaths and serious injuries including amputation of limbs to over
5,00,000 persons. One serious road accident in the country occurs every minute; and one person dies in a road traffic accident every 4 minutes.
Road traffic accidents, therefore, have the potential of being one of the
largest challenges to orderly human existence necessitating immediate and
urgent intervention. Not only the existing laws, which by themselves are
inadequate, are not being implemented in the right earnest; the need for
changes in such laws and upgradation thereof, though admitted, are yet to
see the light of the day. Besides, victims of road traffic accidents die
in large numbers due to lack of timely and proper medical attention
which, inter alia, is caused by avoidable disputes with regard to
jurisdiction of the administrative authorities including the police who
are to deal with the matter instead of rendering immediate medical aid to
the victim. Failure to provide immediate medical attention resulting in
death and irreversible injuries is also due to inadequate facilities for
early removal of the victims of road accident to the nearest
hospitals/medical centres. Inadequate number of ambulances and other
suitable modes of transport to transport the victims of road accidents;
the absence of trauma centres in different hospitals, and lack of even
basic health care facilities are additional features that contribute to
the unimpeded growth of the imminent menace to human life. Such unabated
growth, it may be mentioned, is reflected in the figures beyond 2010
also. In fact, the corresponding figures of the year 2012 available in
''Accidental Deaths and Suicides in 2012 '' a publication of the National
Crime Records Bureau show a uniform graph for all the relevant figures
i.e. number of road accidents; fatal cases as well as serious injury
cases.
The petitioner has not visualized the magnitude of the problem that he seeks to highlight on the basis of his individual perceptions. He seeks
to base his contentions on reports submitted by the Working Groups
constituted by the MoRTH to survey the different facets of the problem as
well as research and authoritative articles published on the subject by
persons of eminence. It will, therefore, be necessary to briefly outline
what has been dealt with and indicated in the said reports and
publications.
(3.)AT the outset, there are the reports of four Working Groups set up by the first respondent to submit recommendations and suggestions on short
term and long term measures to curb road accidents in the country. The
said four Working Groups were required to go into four 'Es ' of road
safety, namely, Engineering, Enforcement, Education and Emergency Care.
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.