JUDGEMENT
-
(1.) Unlike natural calamities that are beyond human control, avoidable
disasters resulting from human error/negligence prove more tragic and
completely imbalance the inter-generational equity and cause irretrievable
damage to the health and environment for generations to come. Such tragedy
may occur from pure negligence, contributory negligence or even failure to
take necessary precautions in carrying on certain industrial activities.
More often than not, the affected parties have to face avoidable damage and
adversity that results from such disasters. The magnitude and extent of
adverse impact on the financial soundness, social health and upbringing of
younger generation, including progenies, may have been beyond human
expectations. In such situations and where the laws are silent or are
inadequate, the courts have unexceptionally stepped in to bridge the gaps,
to provide for appropriate directions and guidelines to ensure that
fundamentals of Article 21 of the Constitution of India (for short "the
Constitution") are not violated.
(2.) The Bhopal Gas Tragedy is a glaring example of such imbalances and
adverse impacts, where by court's intervention, poor and destitute have
been provided relief and rehabilitation.
(3.) The Bhopal Gas Leak Disaster occurred on the intervening night of the
2nd/3rd of December, 1984. Data reflecting the exact number of affected
persons was not available initially. Earlier, it was felt that only a
small number of persons were adversely affected in terms of health or
otherwise by the leakage of toxic gases from the Union Carbide Unit at
Bhopal. However, the Scientific Commission for Continuing Studies on
Effects of Bhopal Gas Leakage on Life Systems (for short the 'Scientific
Commission') released a Report titled 'The Bhopal Gas Disaster: Effects on
Life Systems' in July, 1987 which suggested otherwise. This Report stated
that for the estimated population of 2,00,000 exposed to the toxic gases in
the severely and moderately affected areas of Bhopal and the variety of
long-term problems anticipated in the crisis period, the number of exposees
covered so far by the Indian Council of Medical Research (for short the
'ICMR') through the epidemiological surveys constitute less than 20 per
cent of the population. With the passage of time, this figure of the
affected population has swollen to nearly 5,00,000. By the same Scientific
Commission, it was also found that in general, the output of the
epidemiological project so far had not equalled the magnitude of the tasks
assigned to them, presumably due to lack of resources, trained staff as
well as physical inputs. An opportunity for mounting such a massive long-
term longitudinal study on a population exposed to a one-time acute
chemical stress may not present itself again and hence it would be a pity
if that opportunity was missed. Various steps were recommended by the
Scientific Commission, from time to time, to tackle the two main aspects of
this disaster. Firstly, health care of the affected victims and secondly,
research work with the object to deal with the acute problems arising from
this disaster on the one hand and to suggest preventive steps on the other.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.