JUDGEMENT
SANJAY KISHAN KAUL,J. -
(1.) One more chance after the last chance. That appears to be what is sought to be urged on behalf of the petitioner, Mr. Yatin Narendra Oza -
counsel with many years standing, President of the Bar Association of the
High Court of Gujarat on many occasions, and an erstwhile designated
Senior Advocate. The privilege of the Senior 's gown has been
withdrawn unanimously by a Full Bench of the Gujarat High Court and
that is what is sought to be assailed in the present petition under Article
32 of the Constitution of India.
(2.) This is not the petitioner 's first run in with the High Court or for that matter the Supreme Court. The problem appears to be that the
petitioner does not seem to keep a balance between his role as a senior
counsel and as President of the Bar Association and, thus, crosses the
Lakshman Rekha repeatedly. In the written note filed on behalf of the
Gujarat High Court (for short 'High Court '), it has been pointed out that
he made certain utterances in 2006 against two named Judges, casting
aspersions on their faith and their allegiance to the Constitution of India
and the laws; claiming that they had instead mortgaged the same with the
political powers that be at that time. This resulted in the issuance of a
notice of contempt on 27.4.2006 and his role was commented upon in the
earlier orders dated 30.8.2006 and 12.10.2006. Though they were finally
expunged by this Court, seeking to give a long rope to the petitioner. The
petitioner 's apology was accepted with an undertaking, which was
reported in Yatin Narendra Oza v. Khemchand Rajaram Koshti and Ors.; 2016 15 SCC 236.
(3.) On 21.03.2020, the petitioner wrote a letter to the Hon 'ble Chief Justice of India making serious allegations against a senior-most Judge of
the High Court in his capacity as President of the Bar Association. The
petitioner then transgressed all limits by circulating the letter in the Bar
Association 's WhatsApp group on 8.6.2020, three days after calling the
High Court a "Gamblers Den ". The WhatsApp messages were circulated
by holding a Press Conference 05.06.2020 ( "Press Conference "),
thereby making allegations of impropriety against the Institution of the
High Court itself.;
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.