Decided on August 25,2020

SOM DUTT Appellant
STATE OF JANDK Respondents


Rajnesh Oswal - (1.)In this appeal, the appellants have questioned the judgment dated 04.02.2012 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Rajouri, whereby the appellants have been convicted under section 435 RPC and sentenced for a simple imprisonment of six months and also a fine of Rs. 1000/- has been imposed on each of the appellant.
(2.)The brief facts necessary for disposal of the appeal are that on 29.05.2006 at 16:00 hours, a written complaint was lodged by the complainant, namely, Parshotam Lal S/o. Sh. Sita Ram R/o Lower Danga (Sair), Tehsil, Kalakote. The said complaint reproduced as under:
"To The S.H.O. Police Station Kalakote.

Subject:- Request for lodging FIR against Sh Som Dutt S/o Late Shri Ram Saran, Smt. Darshana Devi W/O Sh. Som Dutt, Mr. Lucky and Shekinder S/O Sh Som Dutt for construction of a Hut on Kh. No. 625 during stay period, Cutting of Wheat crops of Kh. No. 625 and 567 and got fired the wheat crops of Kh. No. 567.

Sir, Respectfully, I Parshotam Lal S/O Sh Sita Ram R/O Lower Danga (Sair) beg to submit the following few lines regarding the subject cited above for your kind consideration and justice please:-

1. That I am ploughing the land of Kh. No. 625 and 567 since last 13 years. Following documents are enclosed herewith.

2. That On 13-02-2006, the aforesaid person has damage my wheat crops (Copy of my application attached).

3. That on 22-05-06 the aforesaid person have cut down my wheat crops of Kh. No. 625 and 567.

4. That on 25-05-06 at about 1700 hours the aforesaid persons set on fire my wheat crops of Kh. No. 567.

Keeping in View the above facts, it is requested to your highness to look into the matter and lodge necessary FIR against the aforesaid persons under law.

Yours faithfully Dated: 29/05/2006 Parshotam Lal S/O Sh. Sita Ram R/O Lower Danga (Sair) Tehsil Kalakote"

(3.)Pursuant to the said complaint, FIR bearing No. 27/2006 for commission of offence 435 RPC was registered by Police Station, Kalakote against the four accused including the appellants. After the investigation of the case, the challan for commission of offences under sections 435 and 427 RPC was produced against the appellants only and the involvement of others accused was not found in the commission of aforesaid offences. During the investigation it was found that the Survey No. 567, belongs to appellant No. 1 and one Karnail Singh, whereas the land comprising Survey No. 625 is owned by the State but has been recorded in possession of the complainant for the last many others. It was further stated that the appellants cut the wheat crop from the Survey No. 567 on 22.05.2006 and on 25.05.2006 at about 5.00 PM they put it on fire causing a wrongful loss of Rs. 1500/- to the complainant. The charge for commission of offences under sections 435 and 427 RPC was framed by the trial court on 03.11.2006 and the prosecution was directed to lead evidence. The prosecution has produced witnesses, namely, 1. PW Parshotam Lal, 2. PW Krishan Lal, 3. PW Jeet Singh, 4.PW Jet Raj, 5.PW Amar Singh, 6. PW Maqbool Hussain, 7. PW Rattan Lal Patwari and 8. Shabir Ahmed Kohli, Investigating Officer. Besides examination of the witnesses, the prosecution has also proved and relied upon the following documentary evidence:
a. Complaint dated 24.05.2006 (Ex-PW-PL) filed by the complainant marked by the court of CJM Rajouri directing SHO concerned to take necessary action under law on 25.05.2006.

b. Complaint dated 29.05.2006 (Ex-PW-PL/1)filed by the complainant, Parshotam Lal before the SHO Police Station, Kalakote, pursuant to which FIR was registered.

c. Seizure memo, marked as ExPW-MH, d. Copy of the Khasra Girdawari i.e. marked as ExPW-RL, e. Site plan of occurrence i.e. marked as ExPW-BA.


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.