- (1.)Petitioners were tried in case FIR No. 152/88 registered at Police Station Valtoha under Sections 326, 325, 324, 323, 149 IPC. It is stated that complainant Bachan Lal and his brother Dharam Pal had agricultural land in village Toot. They had constructed their houses on their land. Adjoining land belongs to petitioners' party i.e. Bahali Ram and others. On 24.11.1988 at 7.30 A.M. on the issue of demolishing common Vat, the present occurrence had arisen. Accused, who were armed, caused injuries to Bachan Lal and Dharam Pal. On the noise raised, Pritam Kaur and Nirmal Dass were attracted to the spot. Pritam Kaur was also injured. All the three injured were taken to hospital by Nirmal Dass. Injured Bachan Lal, Dharam Pal and Pritam Kaur appeared as PW.1, PW.2 and PW.3, respectively. A perusal of both the judgments of Courts below show that they had deposed regarding the injuries inflicted upon them by the accused. Dharam Pal had suffered three injuries, Bachan Lal had suffered 12 injuries and Pritam Kaur had suffered eight injuries. Injured will be the last person to depose falsely as their presence at the spot is stamped. Both the Courts below have rightly convicted and sentenced the petitioners. Sentences awarded to the petitioners are reproduced below:-
Offence committedName of the accusedSentence awarded

U/S 148 IPCAll the accusedUndergo RI for one year each.

U/S 326 IPCBahali RamUndergo RI for two years and to pay fine of Rs.500/-. In default of payment of fine further undergo RI for three months.

U/s 326/149 IPCOther accusedUndergo RI for one year each and to pay fine of Rs.500/- each. In default of payment of fine undergo RI for three months.

U/S 325 IPCMela RamUndergo RI for 1-1/2 years.

U/S 325/148 IPCOther accusedUndergo RI for one year each.

U/S 324 IPCBhalla accusedUndergo RI for one year.

U/S 324/149 IPCOther accusedUndergo RI for nine months each.

U/S 323 IPCAll the accusedUndergo RI for three months each.

All the sentence shall run concurrently. File be consigned to the record Room".

(2.)In this case only Bahali Ram was awarded two years, Mela Ram was awarded 1= years and other accused were awarded one year rigorous imprisonment. Occurrence in the present case pertains to November 1988. A period of more than 19 years has lapsed. Petitioners have suffered protracted trial. Petitioners have also undergone about one month after their appeal was dismissed.
(3.)I find no reason to send the petitioners behind the bar after 19 years. However, learned Appellate Court had noticed that Bachan Lal complainant had suffered injury which had caused permanent bent to his right forearm.