UNION OF INDIA Vs. K P MANDAL
LAWS(CAL)-1960-4-1
HIGH COURT OF CALCUTTA
Decided on April 27,1960

UNION OF INDIA (UOI) Appellant
VERSUS
K.P.MANDAL Respondents

JUDGEMENT

P.C.Mallick, J. - (1.) THIS Notice was taken out by the Union of India for an order that a judgment be passed in accordance with the award made by the Arbitrator on May 23, 1952 and a previous order passed by Sarkar J. on July 20, 1954 be recalled and/or set aside, if necessary.
(2.) DISPUTE between the parties of and relating to a contract containing an arbitration clause was referred to the arbitration of a Superintending Engineer one C. P. Mallik. The Arbitrator made his award on May, 23, 1952 in favour of the petitioner and the respondent was directed to pay the sum of Rs. 16,247/8/-. On January 15, 1953 the respondent made an application for setting aside the award. By his order dated June 16, 1954 Sarkar J. set aside the award. On July 20, 1954 Sarkar J. made a further order directing that no judgment be passed in terms of the award. Against the order of Sarkar J. passed on June 16, 1954 setting aside the award, an appeal was taken by the Union of India. No appeal, however, was taken against the order dated July 20, 1954 refusing to pass a judgment on award. On April 3, 1958 the Appeal Court allowed the appeal and the order of Sarkar J. passed on June 16, 1954 was set aside. The award was confirmed and the application to set aside the award was dismissed. The Order dated July 20, 1954 passed by Sarkar J. was not however set aside inasmuch as no appeal was taken against it, nor was its existence brought to the notice of the Appeal Court while disposing of the appeal.
(3.) ON July 20, 1959 the present Notice was taken out by the Union of India for an order that a judgment be passed in accordance with the award and that the order of Sarkar J. dated July 20, 1954 be set aside and/or recalled, if necessary.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.