COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX Vs. NEW GREAT INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
LAWS(BOM)-1972-7-4
HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Decided on July 19,1972

COMMISSIONER OF INCOME TAX Appellant
VERSUS
New Great Insurance Company Limited Respondents

JUDGEMENT

KOTVAL, J. - (1.) THE judgment in this income -tax reference shall also govern the disposal of I.T. Reference No. 9 of 1971 and I.T. Reference No. 97 of 1971. These three references involve the same point and substantially raise the same question. They were also argued together.
(2.) THE respondents in each of the these three references are insurance companies doing general insurance business and each of these companies derived an income which consists of dividends arising out of their investments. These dividends are received from Indian companies. The short question is whether the dividend income received by the three respondent companies is wholly exempt from super -tax either under provisions of section 99(1)(iv) (as it then stood) of the Income -tax Act, 1961, or under section 85A of the said Act. In Income -tax Reference No. 9 of 1971, the respondent -assessee has also claimed exemption under the provisions of section 85 and section 235 of the same Act in respect of dividend income. In each of the cases the department has claimed that exemption no doubt can be allowed but not upon the full amount of the dividend received by each company but only on the net dividend earned, that is to say, after the deduction of proportionate expenses of management from the total amount of the dividend. In the Income -tax Reference No. 60 of 1971, in the case of the New Great Insurance Co. Ltd. the total income, the total expenses and the total dividend received fin the account year which is the calendar year 1962 (assessment year 1963 -64) were as under : Rs.Total Income 10,25,974Total expenses 37,97,480Total dividend received 3,49,952
(3.) IN Income -tax Reference No. 9 of 1971, in the case of the Indian Guarantee and General Insurance Co. Ltd., the position was as under for the account year, which is the calendar year 1964 (assessment year 1965 -66) : Rs.Total Income 30,19,041Total expenses 4,25,476Total dividend received 15,61,163;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.