JUDGEMENT
VIJAY MANOHAR SAHAI -
(1.)WE have heard Ms.Megha Jani, learned advocate for the petitioners and Mr.Jayant Bhatt, learned
advocate for the respondent.
(2.)THE respondent Jamnagar Municipal Corporation floated a tender, inviting bids
for sale of piece of land. The petitioner
made his bid and deposited Rs.1,58,05,000.00.
The land could not be sold to the petitioner,
as it was objected by the nearby residents.
The bid is likely to be cancelled by the
respondent as stated by the respondent.
The learned counsel for the petitioners urged that if the respondent is going to cancel the
bid, then, the amount deposited by the
petitioner may be refunded along with 18%
interest.
(3.)LEARNED counsel for the respondent has urged that in the tender notice, in paragraph 8, it
was clearly mentioned that if the offer made
by any party is revoked, then, no interest or
compensation can be claimed by the tenderer.
The relevant translated version of paragraph
8 of the tender notice reads as under:-
"8) Out of received offers at any point of time or at any time if the offer of the order is revoked then against such offer filled by the person giving offer any amount of loss and damage or any interest or compensation cannot be claimed"
Thus, the condition of the tender is very
much clear that the bidder is not entitled to
claim any interest on any amount paid as
deposit or otherwise, if bid or order is
cancelled at any point of time. It is clear
from the record that, even today, bid is not
cancelled and petitioner has prayed for a
writ of mandamus to execute the sale-deed
whereas prayer for refund of amount is made
as an alternative relief only and that
petitioner has neither demanded the amount
from the respondent nor the respondent has
yet cancelled the bid. Therefore, the
question of interest does not arise at all.
Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.