ASIATIC GOVERNMENT SECURITY FIRE AND GENERAL ASSURANCE CO., LTD. Vs. SCINDIA STEAM NAVIGATION CO., LTD., BOMBAY
LAWS(KER)-1964-12-41
HIGH COURT OF KERALA
Decided on December 15,1964

Asiatic Government Security Fire And General Assurance Co., Ltd. Appellant
VERSUS
Scindia Steam Navigation Co., Ltd., Bombay Respondents

JUDGEMENT

M.S. Menon, J. - (1.) THE plaintiff in O. S. No. 67 of 1958 of the Munsif's Court of Cochin, the Asiatic Government Security Fire and General Assurance Company Limited, is the appellant in this second appeal. It was the respondent in A.S. No. 131 of 1959 of the Sub Court of Cochin, the successful appeal filed by the respondent before us, the Scindia Steam Navigation Company Limited. The Travancore -Cochin Prawn Curers' Co -operative Marketing Society Limited shipped a consignment of five hundred bags of prawns from Cochin to Rangoon by S.S. Jalatapi, a vessel belonging to the respondent. The goods shipped were insured with the appellant against the risk, among other things, of damage caused by "Rain &/or Fresh &/or Sea &/or River Water" (Ext. P. 1).
(2.) TWENTY -eight bags out of the shipment of five hundred bags were damaged by contact with fresh water and the appellant settled the claim in respect of the said damage by the payment of a sum of Rs. 3,282/ - The suit is to recover that sum from the respondent. There has been no assignment of the rights under the policy in favour of the appellant; and the first question for determination is whether the appellant is entitled to maintain a suit in its own name in the absence of such an assignment. The answer to the question depends on the true scope and effect of section 135A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882.
(3.) SECTION 135A was inserted into the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, by the Transfer of Property (Amendment) Act, 1944. Before the amendment the assignment of rights under both marine and fire insurance policies was governed by section 135. What the amendment did was to take marine insurance policies out of section 135 and provide for them in the new section 135A.;


Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.