RAMVILLAS(DEAD)THR.LRS.&ANR. Vs. KARIM KHAN & ANR.
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Karim Khan And Anr.
Click here to view full judgement.
(1.) The present appeal arises out of the judgment of the High Court of Judicature of Madhya Pradesh, Jabalpur: Bench at
Gwalior in Second Appeal No.374 of 1998 dated 22.06.2005,
confirming the findings of the Courts below that the Sale Deed
executed in favour of the appellants-defendants was only a
mortgage as a security for repayment of the loan taken by the
(2.) It is not necessary for us to refer to the pleadings of the 1st respondent-plaintiff and the appellants-defendants as they are referred in detail in the judgments of the Courts below.
(3.) Challenging the concurrent findings of the Courts below, the learned counsel for the appellants-defendants Mr. Puneet Jain
submitted that whenever a conveyance of the property by a Sale
Deed is accompanied by a separate document, it has to be taken
as re-conveyance and it was not a mortgage and the Courts below
erred in holding that the Sale Deed dated 14.06.1972 in favour
of the appellants-defendants was a security for the loan taken
by the 1st respondent-plaintiff. Learned counsel further
submitted that the Sale Deed was accompanied by an Agreement
Exhibit P/1 dated 14.06.1972 under which the 1st
respondent-plaintiff had agreed to pay an amount of Rs.5000/-
by 14.06.1973, which the 1st respondent-plaintiff did not comply
with, and subsequent Agreement Exhibit P/2 dated 05.06.1974 was
executed under which the 1st respondent-plaintiff paid an amount
of Rs.6700/-; and after a lapse of about 17 years, the 1st
respondent-plaintiff filed the suit for declaration that the
Sale Deed was null and void. It was further submitted that in
the absence of a prayer for cancellation of the Sale Deed dated
14.06.1972, the suit filed by the 1st respondent-plaintiff ought to have been dismissed, more so, when the suit was filed nearly
after a gap of 17 years from the date of execution of the Sale
Deed i.e 14.06.1972. In support of his contention, learned
counsel placed reliance on a number of judgments of this Court
reported as Bishwanath Prasad Singh v. Rajendra Prasad and Anr.
- (2006) 4 SCC 432, Raj Kishore (Dead) by LRs. v. Prem Singh
and Ors. - (2011) 1 SCC 657 and Gauri Shankar Prasad and Ors.
v. Brahma Nand Singh - (2008) 8 SCC 287.;
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.