Decided on April 25,2016

Indian Hotel And Restaurant Association And Another Appellant


- (1.) In pursuance of our Order dated 18.4.2016, Mr. Pradip Bhalchandra Sawant, Deputy Commissioner of Police, Headquarters-I, (Hotel Division), is personally present. He has also filed an affidavit. Relying on the affidavit, it is submitted by Ms. Pinky Anand, learned senior counsel appearing for the State of Maharashtra that most of the applicants have not complied with any of the conditions imposed by this Court and some have complied with in part and that is why licenses have not been granted. Learned senior counsel has prepared a chart which is a part of the affidavit. We intend to advert to serial Nos. 1, 2, 25, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32 and 33 of the chart. The deficiencies pointed out as far as the said applicants are concerned, are as follows: JUDGEMENT_124_LAWS(SC)4_2016.html
(2.) It is submitted by Mr. Bhushan, learned senior counsel that BMC, Health Department has already given the licence. The Department has communicated that there is nothing called 'no objection' as it does not come under the purview of the health department and, therefore, it cannot be given. In our considered opinion when a hotel/restaurant is given the license by the concerned health department and there is a communication in the language which has been mentioned herein above further NOC from it is not necessary.
(3.) As far as the second condition is concerned, it states that the conditions laid down by the Chief Fire Officer are not followed strictly. We fail to fathom that how can it be followed strictly when the license has not been given. When there is a hotel and restaurant and there is fire license, we are inclined to think that meets the said condition. Needless to say if there would be any violation in future, appropriate action can be taken. The other condition pertains to obtaining of certificate from Rangbhumi Prayog Parinirikshan Mandal. The said certificate, as we understand can only be obtained after license is obtained not prior to that. It is because it is stated that action pertains to the arena of supervision and the supervision can only take place after the license is granted. The next condition relates to verification of criminal antecedent of employees. The said stipulation is absolutely necessary and, therefore, we direct that if any of the hotel owners has applied the verifications shall take place by the local police within a week hence and if there is no application then the same shall be done by 26.4.2016 so that steps can be taken accordingly. The other deficiencies as per the chart are increase of railing of 3 ft. height adjacent to the dance stage and maintenance of distance of 5 ft. between non-removable railing and the seats for the customers. The said deficiencies shall be made good within seven days hence. Mr. Sawant shall get it verified after being intimated about the compliance.;

Click here to view full judgement.
Copyright © Regent Computronics Pvt.Ltd.